Markor 2.10.2 can't write/edit SD Card files

[chromer030]

⚠️ This issue respects the following points: ⚠️

• This is a bug. Not a question or feature request.
• The issue is not already reported at Issues or discussions. (I've searched it).
• Markor is up to date. See Releases for the latest version. Updates are available from F-Droid and GitHub.

Description

Markor 2.10.2 can't edit files on sdcard while permission is granted.
Save button doesn't work and all the changes will be discard by closing the app or leaving the note.
Version 2.10.1 was OK.

Markor can write and edit files in SD Card Appdata but not on specified folder in SD Card.
(I cleared the data and cache , uninstall the app and reinstall it but the issue persists.)

Steps to reproduce

1. Specify a folder on SD Card for notebook
2. Try to edit a file.
3. Save button doesn't work.

Information

Android version: 7.1.2 arm64
Device: Lenovo
App Version: 2.10.2

Source

GitHub Releases

Format / File type

Markdown

Additional info / Log

Tested on another device with following specification and whole the procedure :
Device : Asus Zenfone
Android : 10 arm64 lineage
Markor : 2.10.2
SD Card filesystem : fat32 , formatted by android

Procedure :
Installing Markor > Settings > General > Notebook > Selecting F941-7CDA which is root of SD Card and granting permission > navigating to a folder for example Download > Select this folder > Now the + button for adding file doesn't work > creating a text file with OS file manager > Open markor again > opening file > writing something > save button doesn't work !

tested version 2.10.1 with this device and both + and save buttons working.

[gsantner]

....I extra asked before the update if sdcard work, and I got as response (#603) by multiple users that it works. And it works on my device very well too 🤷.

Do you have any newer device by hand (i.e. Android>=10)?

Now we have it there and somebody needs to fix it it looks like....
Just saying, SD Card is a frequently asked topic, but in the many years of Markor never somebody contributed something for SD Card support. Help is totally welcome. Android storage & SD cards is a every-year-changing topic that is very hard to make work across all Android versions.

Related: #1359 #1521 #603

[chromer030]

Using a folder in Internal Storage is OK on both android 7.1.2 and 10.
Both + and Saving buttons working.
(/storage/emulated/0)

[gsantner]

@chromer030
You will find a android-apk download button here. Can you please try that test app if it works for you & sdcard?

https://github.com/gsantner/markor/actions/runs/2875725644

[chromer030]

Tested the Mordor app and confirm that latest commit fixed the issue.
Tested on both 7.1.2 and 10.

[gsantner]

Thanks, good to hear and thanks for reporting.

[chromer030]

Thank you for fixing it fast.

[gsantner]

Usually it's not that easy. This one was some check not triggering with SAF 😄 .