Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Noscript Chrome extension 12.0.7 not compatible with Kiwi Browser. #398

Open
possom2009 opened this issue Dec 1, 2024 · 27 comments
Open
Assignees
Labels
mv3 Manifest V3-specific bug question Further information is requested

Comments

@possom2009
Copy link

After the extension updated for Chrome, all sites are blank unless the extension is disabled.

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 1, 2024

Can confirm, 11.4.44 on the other hand does work...

@hackademix
Copy link
Owner

What does the console say?
Have you got other extensions which may block local network requests, e.g. uBlock, and does disabling them temporarily help?

@hackademix hackademix self-assigned this Dec 1, 2024
@hackademix hackademix added question Further information is requested mv3 Manifest V3-specific bug labels Dec 1, 2024
@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 1, 2024

Do you mean something like this?

Screenshot_com kiwibrowser browser dev

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 1, 2024

I disabled uBlock which didn't help...

@possom2009
Copy link
Author

What does the console say? Have you got other extensions which may block local network requests, e.g. uBlock, and does disabling them temporarily help?

Problem still occurs after disabling uBlock. Here's what the console says.

screenshot

@hackademix
Copy link
Owner

Which Chrome version are you using?

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 1, 2024

Screenshot_2024-12-01-18-10-30-590_com kiwibrowser browser dev-edit

@possom2009
Copy link
Author

Which Chrome version are you using?

Kiwi Browser 124.0.6327.2

@hackademix hackademix changed the title Noscript Chrome extension 12.0.7. Need to disable extension to load sites. Noscript Chrome extension 12.0.7 not compatible with Kiwi Browser. Dec 1, 2024
@hackademix
Copy link
Owner

Kiwi Browser 124.0.6327.2

So it seems you (reporters on this bug) are both using this browser.

Is the version number on par with Chromium? Because it would explain your problems, since the declarativeNetRequest.RuleCondition.responseHeaders API is available only on versions >= 128

Questions:

  1. Was any of the previous 12.0.x versions working for you?
  2. Is a Kiwi browser based on a recent Chromium available?

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 1, 2024

Question 1:
Since I have only had the problems for 2 or 3 days, I assume that one of the last versions still worked.
Question 2:
My Kiwi version is based on Chrome 124.0.6327.4 and unfortunately there is no newer Version

@possom2009
Copy link
Author

possom2009 commented Dec 2, 2024

Question 1: Since I have only had the problems for 2 or 3 days, I assume that one of the last versions still worked. Question 2: My Kiwi version is based on Chrome 124.0.6327.4 and unfortunately there is no newer Version

Same here. Although my version of the browser isn't a dev build.

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 2, 2024

I have the same problem on the regular version. I only installed the developer version additionally because I need two separate installations.

hackademix added a commit that referenced this issue Dec 2, 2024
@hackademix
Copy link
Owner

Please check if 12.0.8 fixes this issue, thanks.

@possom2009
Copy link
Author

possom2009 commented Dec 2, 2024

Please check if 12.0.8 fixes this issue, thanks.

That one works. Everything seems to work now, no more blank pages.

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 2, 2024

Unfortunately I'm getting errors and pages don't load correctly.
Screenshot_2024-12-02-13-21-43-813_com kiwibrowser browser dev-edit
Screenshot_2024-12-02-13-22-26-367_com kiwibrowser browser dev-edit

@hackademix
Copy link
Owner

Unfortunately I'm getting errors and pages don't load correctly.

Those messages do not actually indicate any critical problem.

Could you provide more information about the pages not loading correctly?

Do they work correctly on legacy version 11.4.44?

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 2, 2024

e.g. duduckgo.com:
Screenshot_2024-12-02-14-23-04-769_com kiwibrowser browser dev-edit

Fehler
Error: Could not establish connection. Receiving end does not exist. Cannot collect noscript activity data at Object.collectSeen (chrome-extension://ijnkidnfkalopikbnpbiaejigkifnoln/bg/main.js:448:11) at async onActivatedTab (chrome-extension://ijnkidnfkalopikbnpbiaejigkifnoln/bg/RequestGuard.js:251:18)
Chrome is blocking ads on this site because this site tends to show ads that interrupt, distract, mislead, or prevent user control. You should fix the issues as soon as possible and submit your site for another review. Learn more at https://www.chromestatus.com/feature/5738264052891648
Uncaught (in promise) Error: Cannot access a chrome-extension:// URL of different extension
Chrome is blocking ads on this site because this site tends to show ads that interrupt, distract, mislead, or prevent user control. You should fix the issues as soon as possible and submit your site for another review. Learn more at https://www.chromestatus.com/feature/5738264052891648
Uncaught (in promise) ReferenceError: url is not defined

@hackademix
Copy link
Owner

@C-O-D are you're sure you're on 12.0.8?

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 2, 2024

@C-O-D are you're sure you're on 12.0.8?

Absolutely
Screenshot_2024-12-02-14-48-56-246_com kiwibrowser browser dev-edit

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 2, 2024

@hackademix But you know what in the course of all this action I realized how long there has been no update for Kiwi Browser and as it turns out the project is probably dead. So I'll have to find another browser anyway and until then I can live with using the legacy version 11 of no script. This new browser will most likely be a Firefox derivative of some kind, as I can't find any other Chrome-based browsers with extension support - and Firefox browsers are not affected by this problem here.
In any case, thank you very much for your spontaneous support which I really appreciate 👍

@hackademix
Copy link
Owner

This new browser will most likely be a Firefox derivative of some kind

Yes, I strongly recommend Firefox for Android

thank you very much for your spontaneous support which I really appreciate 👍

You're welcome ❤️

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 2, 2024

@hackademix Oops, would you mind briefly explaining why you recommend Firefox so highly for Android? Security-related reasons?

@hackademix
Copy link
Owner

Oops, would you mind briefly explaining why you recommend Firefox so highly for Android? Security-related reasons?

  • Actively developed
  • Free and open source
  • Many eyes on its security and privacy features, because it's the upstream for the Tor Browser for Android
  • Extensions support far beyond any Chromium derivative (see https://noscript.net/usage/#limitations-on-chromium )
  • Keeping Gecko alive helps the browser ecosystem not to become a stagnant Google-dependent monopoly

@C-O-D
Copy link

C-O-D commented Dec 2, 2024

Oops, would you mind briefly explaining why you recommend Firefox so highly for Android? Security-related reasons?

  • Actively developed
  • Free and open source
  • Many eyes on its security and privacy features, because it's the upstream for the Tor Browser for Android
  • Extensions support far beyond any Chromium derivative (see https://noscript.net/usage/#limitations-on-chromium )
  • Keeping Gecko alive helps the browser ecosystem not to become a stagnant Google-dependent monopoly

All right, that makes sense - thank you very much!

@possom2009
Copy link
Author

Thanks for the quick response for this issue. Will the chrome store version be updated to 12.0.8 soon?

@hackademix
Copy link
Owner

Will the chrome store version be updated to 12.0.8 soon?

Hard to say: I've submitted it this morning, at the same time as I've asked here to try its preview, but Chrome Store's review times are pretty unpredictable, ranging from hours to days or weeks. NoScript has an average of a couple days.

@possom2009
Copy link
Author

Will the chrome store version be updated to 12.0.8 soon?

Hard to say: I've submitted it this morning, at the same time as I've asked here to try its preview, but Chrome Store's review times are pretty unpredictable, ranging from hours to days or weeks. NoScript has an average of a couple days.

Oh, ok. Thanks!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
mv3 Manifest V3-specific bug question Further information is requested
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants