Skip to content

Conversation

@red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03
Copy link
Contributor

@red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03 red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03 bot commented Nov 6, 2025

This PR contains the following updates:

Package Type Update Change
registry.access.redhat.com/ubi9/go-toolset stage major 1.24.6-1763038106 -> 9.7-1763038106

Configuration

📅 Schedule: Branch creation - At any time (no schedule defined), Automerge - At any time (no schedule defined).

🚦 Automerge: Disabled by config. Please merge this manually once you are satisfied.

Rebasing: Whenever PR becomes conflicted, or you tick the rebase/retry checkbox.

🔕 Ignore: Close this PR and you won't be reminded about this update again.


  • If you want to rebase/retry this PR, check this box

To execute skipped test pipelines write comment /ok-to-test.


Documentation

Find out how to configure dependency updates in MintMaker documentation or see all available configuration options in Renovate documentation.

@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented Nov 6, 2025

⚠️ This PR contains a major version update and requires manual review before merging. Add the no-automerge label if you want to prevent auto-merge in the future.

@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Nov 6, 2025

Code Review - PR #55: Update go-toolset Docker tag

Summary

This PR updates the base builder image from registry.access.redhat.com/ubi9/go-toolset:1.24.6-1762373805 to registry.access.redhat.com/ubi9/go-toolset:9.6-1762373805.


⚠️ Critical Issues

1. Unclear Version Semantics (BLOCKER)

The tag change from 1.24.6-1762373805 to 9.6-1762373805 is confusing and potentially problematic:

  • Old tag: 1.24.6 appears to explicitly reference Go version 1.24.6
  • New tag: 9.6 likely refers to RHEL UBI 9.6, NOT Go 1.24.6

Impact: This change may inadvertently downgrade the Go version or introduce an incompatible Go toolchain.

Recommendation:

  • ✅ Verify that 9.6-1762373805 includes Go 1.24.x or later (required by go.mod)
  • ✅ Check Red Hat container catalog to confirm the Go version in this tag
  • ✅ Consider if you want to pin to specific Go versions (like 1.24.6) or track UBI releases (like 9.6)

2. Tag Strategy Inconsistency

The old tag (1.24.6-1762373805) appears to follow a Go-version-first naming pattern, while the new tag (9.6-1762373805) follows a RHEL-version-first pattern. This suggests a change in Red Hat's tagging strategy.

Questions to answer:

  • Is 9.6-1762373805 the new canonical tag format from Red Hat?
  • Does Red Hat still maintain 1.24.x-* tags for Go version tracking?
  • What happens when Go 1.25 is released - will you need to manually update to 9.7 or similar?

📋 Code Quality & Best Practices

Positive Points ✅

  • Single-line change minimizes risk
  • Automated via MintMaker/Renovate bot - good dependency management practice
  • Build digest is pinned (1762373805) for reproducibility

Concerns ⚠️

Build Verification

  • No indication that the build was tested with the new base image
  • Action: Ensure CI passes before merging
  • Action: Verify multi-arch builds (amd64/arm64) work with new base image

Compatibility

  • Project requires Go 1.24.0+ (go.mod line 3)
  • Toolchain specifies go1.24.4 (go.mod line 5)
  • CI workflows use Go 1.24 (test.yml lines 21, 52, 72, 95)
  • Action: Confirm the new image provides a compatible Go version

🔒 Security Considerations

Good: Using Red Hat's official UBI images from verified registry
Good: Pinning to specific digest for supply chain security
⚠️ Note: Runtime image (ubi-minimal:latest) uses latest tag - consider pinning this too for consistency


🧪 Test Coverage

Missing: No indication of build/test execution with new base image

Recommendations:

  1. Wait for CI to pass (especially the Build job in .github/workflows/test.yml)
  2. Consider manual testing: make build && make test-unit
  3. Test container build: podman build -f Containerfile .

🎯 Recommendations

Before Merging:

  1. REQUIRED: Verify Go version in 9.6-1762373805 meets project requirements (≥1.24.0)
  2. REQUIRED: Ensure all CI checks pass
  3. RECOMMENDED: Test build locally or in CI
  4. RECOMMENDED: Document the tagging strategy (Go version vs UBI version) in Containerfile comments

Optional Improvements:

  • Add a comment in Containerfile explaining the tag format
  • Consider pinning the runtime image (ubi-minimal:latest) to a specific version
  • Add renovate/mintmaker configuration to repository if it's not centrally managed

📝 Documentation Impact

No documentation updates needed for this change, but consider adding:

  • Comment in Containerfile about base image version strategy
  • Note in CLAUDE.md about container image dependencies

Final Verdict

Status: ⏸️ NEEDS VERIFICATION

This appears to be an automated dependency update, but the tag naming change from Go-version-based to UBI-version-based is concerning. Before approving:

  1. Confirm the Go version compatibility
  2. Ensure CI passes
  3. Verify the build still works as expected

Once verified, this is a reasonable maintenance update to track UBI 9.6 releases.


Review generated by Claude Code

@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented Nov 6, 2025

⚠️ This PR contains a major version update and requires manual review before merging. Add the no-automerge label if you want to prevent auto-merge in the future.

@red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03 red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03 bot force-pushed the konflux/mintmaker/main/registry.access.redhat.com-ubi9-go-toolset-9.x branch from 33ffa23 to 930366d Compare November 12, 2025 04:31
@github-actions
Copy link

⚠️ This PR contains a major version update and requires manual review before merging. Add the no-automerge label if you want to prevent auto-merge in the future.

@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Nov 12, 2025

Code Review - PR #55: Update go-toolset Docker tag

Summary

This PR updates the base builder image from ubi9/go-toolset:1.24.6-1762373805 to ubi9/go-toolset:9.7-1762230058. This appears to be a Renovate-generated dependency update.

Critical Concerns

⚠️ Go Version Compatibility

Status:BLOCKING ISSUE

The tag change from 1.24.6-1762373805 to 9.7-1762230058 is concerning because:

  1. Project requires Go 1.24+ (per go.mod:3 and CLAUDE.md:175)
  2. Tag format change suggests incompatibility: The old tag 1.24.6-* clearly indicated Go version 1.24.6, while the new tag 9.7-* appears to reference UBI9.7 release version, not the Go version
  3. UBI 9.7 go-toolset typically ships with Go 1.22.x, which is below the required Go 1.24+

Recommendation: Before merging, you must verify the Go version in the new image:

# Test locally
podman run --rm registry.access.redhat.com/ubi9/go-toolset:9.7-1762230058 go version

# Expected: go version go1.24.x linux/amd64
# Likely actual: go version go1.22.x linux/amd64 (incompatible)

If the image contains Go < 1.24, you should:

  • Close this PR and configure Renovate to pin to images with Go 1.24+
  • Consider switching to golang:1.24-alpine or similar if UBI9 doesn't provide Go 1.24 yet
  • Or build from source using a newer toolchain

Code Quality Assessment

✅ Change Scope

  • Minimal and focused: Single line change in Containerfile
  • Clear purpose: Dependency update via automation
  • No logic changes: Only affects build environment

Build Process Validation

The change affects the builder stage only. The multi-stage build should still work if the Go version is compatible:

  • Multi-arch build targets preserved (linux/amd64, linux/arm64)
  • CGO disabled build flags unchanged
  • Runtime image (ubi9/ubi-minimal:latest) unaffected

Testing Recommendations

  1. Verify CI passes - Ensure the build-image workflow completes successfully
  2. Test container build locally:
    make image IMAGE_NAME=test IMAGE_TAG=pr-55
  3. Run tests in the new builder environment to catch any toolchain issues:
    make test-unit
    make test-integration

Security Considerations

✅ Using Red Hat official registry images (trusted source)
⚠️ The new tag uses a digest-based identifier which is good for reproducibility, but verify it points to an expected release


Verdict

🛑 DO NOT MERGE until Go version compatibility is confirmed.

The tag naming convention change strongly suggests this update downgrades the Go toolchain below the required 1.24+ version. This would break the build or cause runtime issues with Go 1.24-specific features.

Next Steps:

  1. Verify the actual Go version in ubi9/go-toolset:9.7-1762230058
  2. If incompatible, update Renovate configuration to filter for Go 1.24+ images only
  3. Consider alternative base images if Red Hat UBI9 doesn't yet support Go 1.24

Review generated by Claude Code

@github-actions
Copy link

⚠️ This PR contains a major version update and requires manual review before merging. Add the no-automerge label if you want to prevent auto-merge in the future.

@red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03 red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03 bot force-pushed the konflux/mintmaker/main/registry.access.redhat.com-ubi9-go-toolset-9.x branch from 930366d to 90aae7f Compare November 13, 2025 20:23
@github-actions
Copy link

⚠️ This PR contains a major version update and requires manual review before merging. Add the no-automerge label if you want to prevent auto-merge in the future.

… tag to v9

Signed-off-by: red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03 <206760901+red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
@red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03 red-hat-konflux-kflux-prd-rh03 bot force-pushed the konflux/mintmaker/main/registry.access.redhat.com-ubi9-go-toolset-9.x branch from 90aae7f to 18c58e7 Compare November 14, 2025 00:37
@github-actions
Copy link

⚠️ This PR contains a major version update and requires manual review before merging. Add the no-automerge label if you want to prevent auto-merge in the future.

@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Nov 14, 2025

Pull Request Review - PR #55

Summary

This PR updates the base image tag in the Containerfile from 1.24.6-1763038106 to 9.7-1763038106. While this appears to be an automated Renovate update, there is a critical issue with this change that needs to be addressed.


🚨 Critical Issue: Incorrect Tag Format

Problem: The tag change from 1.24.6-1763038106 to 9.7-1763038106 represents a shift from a Go version-based tag to a UBI version-based tag.

  • Current tag: 1.24.6-1763038106 - Explicitly specifies Go 1.24.6
  • New tag: 9.7-1763038106 - Specifies UBI 9.7 (but Go version is implicit/unknown)

Why this matters:

  1. The project requires Go 1.24+ according to CLAUDE.md (go.mod:3 specifies go 1.24.0)
  2. Using a UBI version tag instead of a Go version tag makes it unclear which Go version is included
  3. This could lead to unexpected Go version changes in the future when the UBI 9.7 tag is updated
  4. Build reproducibility is reduced - the build-time snapshot is less specific

Recommendation:

  • Do not merge this PR as-is
  • ✅ Configure Renovate to track Go version tags (e.g., 1.24.x-*) instead of UBI version tags
  • ✅ Verify that the new tag actually contains a compatible Go version (likely Go 1.24.x or newer)

Code Quality Assessment

Positive aspects:

  • ✅ Simple, focused change (single line)
  • ✅ Automated dependency management is good practice
  • ✅ The build timestamp portion matches (1763038106), suggesting these images are from the same build

Areas for improvement:

  • The Renovate configuration should be updated to prefer Go version tags over UBI version tags for the go-toolset image

Testing Recommendations

Before merging any version of this change:

  1. Verify Go version: Check what Go version is actually included in 9.7-1763038106
  2. Build test: Run make build with the new image to ensure compatibility
  3. Run test suite: Execute make test-unit and make test-integration to verify no regressions
  4. Check image size: Compare image sizes to ensure no unexpected bloat

Security Considerations

  • ✅ Base image from official Red Hat registry (trusted source)
  • ⚠️ Using version tags instead of digests means builds are not fully reproducible
  • 💡 Consider pinning by digest for maximum reproducibility

Performance Considerations

No significant performance impact expected from this change - it only updates the build-time base image.


Conclusion

Verdict: ❌ Needs changes - Do not merge until tag format issue is resolved.

The tag naming confusion needs to be clarified before proceeding. Please verify:

  1. What Go version is in the 9.7-1763038106 tag?
  2. Is it compatible with the project Go 1.24.0 requirement?
  3. Should Renovate be configured to track Go versions instead?

@github-actions
Copy link

⚠️ This PR contains a major version update and requires manual review before merging. Add the no-automerge label if you want to prevent auto-merge in the future.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant