Synchronized Scrolling in Split Editor

[jcastanza-apollidon]

I have a feature request related to synchronized scrolling in the Split Editor. I checked for extensions and didn't see any. Was wondering if this is the pipeline or not.

[compilenix]

Related #17362

[kkukshtel]

Would love this as well. Synchronized scrolling would allow for easy text diffs, similar to how the version diff works for the source control.

[stereokai]

This doesn't get enough love

[atif089]

bumping this cool request

[alete89]

spreading love

[usaspiff]

I would love to see this feature implemented as well, and be able to see text diffs.

[jeanbenitez]

👍 +1!
I would love to see this too!

[ghaschel]

Would love to see this too

[Tuttu]

Adding my own voice for this addition. 👍

[LailaAli]

Agree, this would be a very handy feature. Are there any updates on this request?

[brandonhc33]

i need this, please!

[alete89]

I'm sure that this will catch @rebornix 's attention soon

[ankedsgn]

Yes, this would be a great addition. 👍🏼

[deckeogh]

I'd love to see this tooooo

[ddeamilivia]

It would be a good addition, and probably not too difficult to implement since it's already implemented on the file comparison, which btw is a nice workaround in the meantime

[subudhiroshan]

Yes please!

[savbran]

👍 +1
It would be great to have this feature to check editing between similar files.

[3rg1s]

Hello I am rooting for this feature to be implemented without an extension.

[brianblakely]

I opened this issue up to +1 it and realized I already did so ages ago.

Neat extension, though!

[storenth]

Why this feature still not released? Sad.

[mymage]

Why this feature still not released? Sad.

Maybe I don't understand. I'm using it since a year... Did you update your version?

[3rg1s]

Why this feature still not released? Sad.

Maybe I don't understand. I'm using it since a year... Did you update your version?

Well I think the ticket should've been closed. Right?

[mymage]

Well I think the ticket should've been closed. Right?

Right

[StendertBroos]

As I am using an ultra wide screen, I would really like to split a single long (.ipynb) file into multiple columns, showing different line ranges per column, scrolling through them in sync.

In general, this allows for efficient use of long files on wide screens.

Optimal would be something like a "broaden file" option with automatic consecutive alignment across columns, based on lines on screen. So if one pane shows X lines, then pane 1 contains line 1 till line X, pane 2 contains line X+1 till line 2X, pane 3 contains line 2X+1 till line 3X, etc.

Echo'ing @3rg1s, I think such a feature would be best implemented natively, and would probably be widely used, even on screens that are not very wide.

On a side note, dqisme's plugin does not work very well when scrolling fast with offset as it changes the offset, and does not work at all for Jupyter Notebooks.

Best!

[Dioarya]

Bump

[Fefedu973]

We need this feature

[Tein-devoteam]

I'm very much in agreement with @StendertBroos's suggestion. How can we promote this feature?

[purpledev1337]

It would be a really appreciated feature!

[hisbvdis]

Thanks, works fine.

From: dq notifications@github.com To:microsoft/vscode vscode@noreply.github.com CC:intellekta uwe.cramer@intellekta.de, Comment comment@noreply.github.com Date: 03.06.2020 00:02 Subject: Re: [microsoft/vscode] Synchronized Scrolling in Split Editor (#33110) Everybody hands up, here comes Sync Scroll ( https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=dqisme.sync-scroll) This extension will help you synchronize scrolling on split editor. Try it out and leave your reviews or issues or PRs. Very glad to hear that. Happy hacking and long lives the open source community. — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub ( #33110 (comment)) , or unsubscribe ( https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADLQHAC3DD372DWJ2R7TMX3RUVZGJANCNFSM4DYHXJBA) .

Unfortunatelly, this extension is not working anymore.

[benibenj]

I'm planning to introduce synchronized scrolling to Visual Studio Code in March and would like to make it as straightforward and practical as possible. To do that, I'm keen to understand the scenarios you envision using it for and how you'd prefer to switch it on or off.

It seems like a lot of the interest is around comparing language files, where both files would scroll together so that each line matches up across files. Do you use a standard format for your language files, or have you developed a custom format?

If there are other scenarios where the current File: Compare Active File With... feature doesn't meet your needs, please let me know.

Regarding how to access this feature, would a command like Synchronize Scroll Active File With... work for you? This would open a side-by-side editor with synchronized scrolling. It would align line number X in the left file with line number X on the right side. Would there be a need to adjust the alignment manually?

I'm open to any feedback or suggestions on how to better implement this feature.

[oshliaer]

@benibenj

Great!

• Check this cool tool https://github.com/dqisme/vscode-sync-scroll/
• My main goal is simultaneous text translation. I need to scroll through many lines in parallel.

[brianblakely]

@benibenj

A less opinionated command like Toggle Synchronized Editor Scrolling would be ideal, which propagates a scroll event in one editor to all active editors in the same window. This would allow me to, for example, open a single large file in two editors, and synchronize scrolling between them as I inspect a list of imported functions versus their references much later on.

[kokoshneta]

@benibenj

If there are other scenarios where the current File: Compare Active File With... feature doesn't meet your needs, please let me know.

Regarding how to access this feature, would a command like Synchronize Scroll Active File With... work for you? This would open a side-by-side editor with synchronized scrolling. It would align line number X in the left file with line number X on the right side. Would there be a need to adjust the alignment manually?

I have used split editors for language files, but more commonly I’ve used it for different versions of the same file, to identify how they differ. Sometimes, that means things like comparing a file in the repository or workspace I have open with a backup file downloaded from a third-party backup system and not located in the same repository/workspace. It also means it’s often the case that lines numbers are not parallel. Code on line 50 in one version may be on line 400 in the version I’m comparing with.

A command like ‘Synchronize Scroll Active File With…’ would be useful, but quite limited.

A much, much more powerful and useful feature would be two toggles located in/on/at/by the scrollbar between adjacent editor panes:

• One to turn synchronised scrolling on/off
• One to match up line numbers

In combination, those would determine which of the three possible scrolling behaviours applies to the two panes:

1. Sync disabled: panes scroll individually (matching line numbers should probably be greyed out when syncing is disabled)
2. Sync enabled, matching disabled: panes scroll up and down in unison based on whatever position the file was in when syncing was enabled; for example, you can stay on line 1 in one pane and scroll down to line 201 in the other, then turn on syncing, and the files will remain parallel, one file 200 lines ahead of the other; wrapped lines in one pane do not affect the other pane
3. Sync + matching enabled: panes scroll in unison based on line numbers, so that the top of the files are positioned next to each other and wrapped lines in one editor results in extra space in the other

That would be the dream scenario for me. It’s quite similar to the plugin linked to by @oshliaer, except that it looks like the plugin just has three modes to choose from as a command, rather than toggles. The benefit of toggles is that they allow you to individually set the syncing and line matching mode not for the window but for two adjacent split editor panes.

That means that if you have your editor split into four panes, you can sync-scroll all four panes, only panes 1+2, panes 1+2 and 3+4 but not 2+3 (giving you two separate, sync-scrolling ‘groups’), etc.

[starball5]

Related on Stack Overflow: Synchronise vertical/horizontal scrolling in split view

More loosely related: How can I make VS Code display a file in a two editor groups, where the bottom line of the left group is always the top of the right one? for people who want to sync a split of the same file, but have one start at the line where the previous ends.

[raffle-x-dev]

Up!

[benibenj]

Tomorrows VSCode Insiders will support the Toggle Locked Scrolling Across Editors which will synchronize the scrolling across all text editors and notebooks. You can also set a keybinding for workbench.action.holdLockedScrolling which will synchronize the scrolling only when being pressed.

Try it out here: https://code.visualstudio.com/insiders/