Introduce share links in more places via a contrib #177311
Conversation
joyceerhl
force-pushed
the
dev/joyceerhl/surviving-swordfish
branch
from
601569f
to
72c7353
Compare
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This PR has a layer breaker and I would also argue that it has a conceptual flaw. You might be able to fix the layer breaking (tho not easy) but generally commands should never just rely on the arguments they are being called with. Any extension can call any command at any time and therefore it is best that commands "discover" their arguments themselves.
| character: selection.getEndPosition().column | ||
| } | ||
| }))] | ||
| }); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This is not OK because it is a conceptual layer breaker. It introduces extension host types to the renderer, e.g this new argument is wrong for all "internal" context menu actions and wrong for monaco-editor use-cases.
| if (this._options?.arg) { | ||
| if (this._options?.arg && Array.isArray(this._options.arg)) { | ||
| runArgs = [...runArgs, ...this._options.arg]; | ||
| } else if (this._options?.arg) { |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I have unfortunately limited capacities for a deeper look but this seems breaking for those cases where use have been using an array as argument, right?
Re: #176316, #175676
I received feedback in #176316 (comment) that introducing multiple share menus, each with their own expected behavior (copying a range, copying a path without a range, and copying neither a path nor a range) is onerous for extensions.
This PR reduces the burden on extensions by passing a more predictable context object to extension-contributed share commands and allowing extensions to register commands in all relevant share submenus with one contrib declaration in package.json. In brief:
It's adopted here for the builtin GitHub extension but also requires adoption in GHPRI and GitHub Repositories.