-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 62
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Rename "albums" to "folders" #457
Conversation
3abe104
to
808c889
Compare
CI is failing because the Webpack build leaves the working tree dirty. I'll push an amended patchset that includes the changes to them, since AFAICT that's what I'm supposed to do? The contributing docs don't mention it (I'm just guessing based on the nextcloud/server README). |
808c889
to
9745113
Compare
Oh, another note: I did not delete localization strings for "Your album" under the assumption that they will be needed soon. (Indeed locally I'm working through adding a virtual albums feature that would use them again.) |
Sorry for the late reply @strugee! I’m not entirely sure about this. We should not have both "Folders" and "Albums" as that will create confusion. Every folder should just be an album (as now, for fallback) and then the new possible Albums implementation should also allow virtual albums. Or what do you think @skjnldsv @karlitschek @jakobroehrl @Mikescops @dassio @nextcloud/photos – since it’s more than just a wording change. |
since you can not configure what is scanned/displayed in the photos app as "albums", I very much support that the current implementation is renamed to just "folders". The cover art of my music collection certainly is not an album and thus should never ever show up as such. Folders are folders and albums are a virtual collection of files from a single or multiple folders. |
To be honest @jancborchardt I'm fine with the Folders rename, it's the truth we just browse the file directory. We shouldn't rely on what things could be in the future because as we know future features can be really far from now. And the current "Album" naming is indeed misleading. |
No strong opinions here to be honest. |
Can we move on here? |
Meant to reply to this and forgot, sorry. I do like @jancborchardt's proposed design (we could call folders "Folder Albums" or something and have an option to hide them, for cases like @da-anda's music cover art) but realistically that feature might be a ways off. I propose we merge this as-is since it more accurately reflects the current feature set. Whoever implements real virtual albums can just revert the name change. If that sounds agreeable to everybody I'll go ahead and rebase this. |
In order to be more clear that the nodes do only list folders containing pictures, I think the shown headlines in the |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Let’s go with the rename then since it indeed reflects the current state. :) We can always adjust later on.
(Just don’t want the navigation to become filled with different terms of "Album" and "Folder" in the long run, to make that clear.)
@strugee please rebase? (you can drop changes for |
@skjnldsv what do you mean drop changes for @da-anda I'm on the fence; I see what you're saying but I think those suggestions would be too wordy for the UI. And it's the Photos app anyway, so I think there's probably enough context for the user. |
For the rebase, you can ignore all conflicts for js files as you will have to recompile them afterwards :) |
9745113
to
e661d03
Compare
This should be ready for merge. |
Ref #120 Signed-off-by: AJ Jordan <alex@strugee.net>
e661d03
to
b8292b6
Compare
/compile amend / |
Ref #120 Signed-off-by: AJ Jordan <alex@strugee.net> Signed-off-by: npmbuildbot[bot] <npmbuildbot[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
b8292b6
to
3f40366
Compare
This more accurately reflects what the feature actually is, and paves the way for the addition of a "real" virtual albums feature as discussed in #120.
This is my first significant contribution to any Nextcloud app, so when reviewing, please do not assume I know what I'm doing :P