File sharing

[johntung]

I login as UserA and share a file with update permission called testing.xls to UserB. UserB logged to the system and made some changes. The problem is that UserB accepted the replacement warning but the file is not replaced. Instead, a file called testing (2).xls appears. If you click on that file, ownCloud tells you that it does not exist.

I believe that it is a bug. Please kindly check.

[MorrisJobke]

cc @MTGap @icewind1991

[johntung]

There is nothing in your comment. Please advise.

[MorrisJobke]

@johntung I've just pulled in the responsible persons

[karlitschek]

@schiesbn Can you check if this still exists?

[PVince81]

I tried the following steps:

1. Login as userA
2. Upload a file "test.txt".
3. Share "test.txt" with userB with "can edit" permission
4. Create a directory "testdir"
5. Upload a file "test.txt" into "testdir".
6. Share "testdir" with userB with "can edit" permission
7. Login as userB
8. Edit "/Shared/test.txt" with the inline text editor and save
9. Edit "/Shared/testdir/test.txt" with the inline text editor and save
10. Upload "test.txt" into "/Shared/testdir" to replace it.

In OC 5.0.13: At step 10, a file "test (2).txt" appears which can correctly be edited, no warning appear.
In OC6 beta 3 (master): At step 10, a file conflict dialog appears. If you choose to keep both files it will create "test (2).txt" which can be opened properly.

If at step 3) and step 6) you pick "can update" instead of "can edit", you will only be able to edit the files through the inline text editor (no upload).

It all seems to work, closing.

@johntung feel free to reopen if you still meet this issue. Thanks.