stubgen often generates incorrect imports

[Diggsey]

In examples like the following:

from x import y

Stubgen will often lose the from x, and simply generate an import like:

import y

[JukkaL]

Can you give a full, self-contained example where this happens?

[Diggsey]

# stubtest/__init__.py

# stubtest/a.py
from . import interfaces

class X(interfaces.Y):
    pass

# stubtest/interfaces.py
class Y:
    pass

> stubgen stubtest.a

# out/stubtest/a.pyi

# Stubs for stubtest.a (Python 3.5)
#
# NOTE: This dynamically typed stub was automatically generated by stubgen.

import interfaces

class X(interfaces.Y): ...

[shangxiao]

stubgen doesn't keep track of imports attempt to resolve imports with the ast; it simply adds "import foo"

[gvanrossum]

If you have an idea on how to fix this, please submit a PR -- we'll gladly review it!

[shangxiao]

Hmm… not sure that the reference above pinged anyone, so bump: #3704

[dmoisset]

I just checked and I think #3169 solved this

[ilevkivskyi]

Yes, it looks like this is fixed now.