Skip to content

Running slideshow/widescreen and slideshow/fullscreen modules directly #19

@LiberalArtist

Description

@LiberalArtist
Contributor

Currently, the only way to control the actual aspect ratio used for #f seems to be extra-linguistically, via the slideshow executable.

I think it would make sense for running a program in #lang slideshow/widescreen or #lang slideshow/fullscreen directly via racket or DrRacket to set the default aspect ratio accordingly. In particular, when using DrRacket to run a module in #lang slideshow/widescreen that incorporates a library slide function with an adaptive aspect ratio, the library slide will currently be in full-screen, which I found surprising.

It might also make sense for running the slideshow executable without an explicit --widescreen or --fullscreen argument to similarly let #lang slideshow/widescreen and #lang slideshow/fullscreen establish the default aspect ratio, though that seems like it would be more complicated to implement.

Activity

mflatt

mflatt commented on Oct 6, 2022

@mflatt
Member

It has been a few years, and things are mostly still in the same state.

I haven't been motivated to improve on the state of the implementation here, because I just moved completely over to widescreen mode. It's nice that slides can be adaptive in principle, but I don't use that. Even when I run old talks, I normally want to modernize a detail or two, and it's easy to adjust to widescreen along the way. (Usually, it's a matter of improving a slide or two that looks needlessly crowded.)

The only thing I wonder is whether it would make sense to switch to widescreen as the default, instead of fullscreen. That way, I don't have to remember how to run slideshow --widescreen --save-aspect when I set up a new machine, and the occasional new Slideshow user would not have to discover that approach. People who have fullscreen slides might need to run slideshow --fullscreen --save-aspect after upgrading Racket, but hopefully that's fewer people than potential future users who want widescreen mode.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

        Participants

        @mflatt@LiberalArtist

        Issue actions

          Running slideshow/widescreen and slideshow/fullscreen modules directly · Issue #19 · racket/slideshow