FileShare-DashBoard: FileShare-Access List Order is not proper

[satya-gorli]

Is this a BUG REPORT or FEATURE REQUEST?:

Uncomment only one, leave it on its own line:

/kind bug

What happened:

1. Create File Share
2. Create Access..
3. Repeat Step 2 with different names..
4. Check the order of the Access Items displayed..
   Not in Created date/Time order.. not by type, not by IP
   What you expected to happen:
   List should display in specific order either sorted by IP or by Creation Date
   How to reproduce it (as minimally and precisely as possible):

Anything else we need to know?:

Environment:

• Hotpot(release/branch) version:
• OS (e.g. from /etc/os-release):
• Kernel (e.g. uname -a):
• Install tools:
• Others:

[Shruthi-1MN]

@satya-gorli , This is extra filter option. It is not in scope to do now. Adding more filter can be done as a separate feature enhancement. It should be done all over the project.

[satya-gorli]

Its not about new Feature.. Current Listing feature can be in a specific order

[Shruthi-1MN]

@satya-gorli , It is by Acl Id in ascending order, to display in user requested order will be new feature.
Please find results which is proof to the order

1. From CLI

root@shruthi-VirtualBox:~/go/src/github.com/opensds/opensds# osdsctl fileshare acl list
WARNING: OPENSDS_ENDPOINT is not specified, use default(http://localhost:50040)
WARNING: Not found Env OPENSDS_AUTH_STRATEGY, use default(noauth)
+--------------------------------------+--------------------------------------+------+------------------+--------------+-----------------+
| Id                                   | FileShareId                          | Type | AccessCapability | AccessTo     | Description     |
+--------------------------------------+--------------------------------------+------+------------------+--------------+-----------------+
| 03267a97-1922-443f-add1-56e179ffb99b | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.2  | file share test |
| 12fd4c5a-df51-4446-aa12-ca1a5b8f39ec | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.2  | file share test |
| 1ba29d07-89d5-4fac-bd54-6b243a080eea | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.6  | file share test |
| 31f0ea53-2523-43d0-9e0c-0203c1372738 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.9  | file share test |
| 37c8767c-dfc3-47ae-859c-86101ea36a9f | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.3  | file share test |
| 3a8f1d77-9d19-4a47-93c7-ea98ba71dcc7 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.3  | file share test |
| 3e3f5cc2-75ae-42e1-8878-58f84e2da724 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.11 | file share test |
| 4e3ba7ef-ac24-4998-b9cf-660669755b67 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.2  | file share test |
| 51eb32f5-4f6a-42c6-b094-b3047c0ea16d | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.2  | file share test |
| 60e810da-b063-48a7-a999-80123b331060 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.8  | file share test |
| 62868c0c-0ca4-4157-97e7-d0bb1031b197 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.2  | file share test |
| 68d02a49-8715-4744-914f-a34808cb261c | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.2  | file share test |
| 7cd5f81a-a07c-472e-a9a9-97a5e6ce118e | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.6  | file share test |
| 825e6217-dca3-4426-ba03-3cdc41cee466 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.7  | file share test |
| 898165cc-b11d-4975-a611-3fd71c596d21 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.5  | file share test |
| 8a382982-fcfc-48da-b634-474ce906c1c0 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.13 | file share test |
| 917779ba-cde9-441a-974c-52b557e1c9bc | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.5  | file share test |
| 9f4149be-22c9-4425-91b4-f35901490397 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.4  | file share test |
| a641fd61-0b24-4f67-8f69-af4912af97ea | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.2  | file share test |
| a8495a47-e80c-4027-9c04-a2d91979438a | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.7  | file share test |
| aea6d04f-ed32-4cb0-afee-036db59cd81d | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.2  | file share test |
| cf5697a3-42f0-47a7-94a3-fc777a085230 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.10 | file share test |
| d3f25a10-d92e-4d34-baa6-cb46415b2467 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.12 | file share test |
| d953a48e-e13e-436e-9b4d-23a2e3248524 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.14 | file share test |
| ebb20f26-09b7-4d05-8225-5f5891e19d76 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.2  | file share test |
| eed1b943-8850-48ae-9731-610d1fae943b | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.4  | file share test |
| f62424a7-5d06-4cc0-85d3-6d3ccb741cac | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.8  | file share test |
| fcdd6f7e-49f2-4dc6-b57a-8aa484486e4b | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.9  | file share test |
| ff4e1c87-11a0-4f93-8382-a202df30c853 | 6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df | ip   | [Read Write]     | 10.32.104.10 | file share test |
+--------------------------------------+--------------------------------------+------+------------------+--------------+-----------------+

2. Form Curl command

root@shruthi-VirtualBox:~/go/src/github.com/opensds/opensds# curl -X GET http://127.0.0.1:50040/v1beta/e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96/file/acls
[{"id":"03267a97-1922-443f-add1-56e179ffb99b","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:41","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:41","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.2","description":"file share test"},{"id":"12fd4c5a-df51-4446-aa12-ca1a5b8f39ec","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:32","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:32","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.2","description":"file share test"},{"id":"1ba29d07-89d5-4fac-bd54-6b243a080eea","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.6","description":"file share test"},{"id":"31f0ea53-2523-43d0-9e0c-0203c1372738","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:10","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:11","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.9","description":"file share test"},{"id":"37c8767c-dfc3-47ae-859c-86101ea36a9f","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:27","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.3","description":"file share test"},{"id":"3a8f1d77-9d19-4a47-93c7-ea98ba71dcc7","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:09","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:09","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.3","description":"file share test"},{"id":"3e3f5cc2-75ae-42e1-8878-58f84e2da724","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:11","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:11","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.11","description":"file share test"},{"id":"4e3ba7ef-ac24-4998-b9cf-660669755b67","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:27","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:27","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.2","description":"file share test"},{"id":"51eb32f5-4f6a-42c6-b094-b3047c0ea16d","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:44","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:45","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.2","description":"file share test"},{"id":"60e810da-b063-48a7-a999-80123b331060","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:10","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:10","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.8","description":"file share test"},{"id":"62868c0c-0ca4-4157-97e7-d0bb1031b197","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:36","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:36","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.2","description":"file share test"},{"id":"68d02a49-8715-4744-914f-a34808cb261c","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:43","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:43","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.2","description":"file share test"},{"id":"7cd5f81a-a07c-472e-a9a9-97a5e6ce118e","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:10","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:10","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.6","description":"file share test"},{"id":"825e6217-dca3-4426-ba03-3cdc41cee466","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:10","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:10","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.7","description":"file share test"},{"id":"898165cc-b11d-4975-a611-3fd71c596d21","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:10","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:10","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.5","description":"file share test"},{"id":"8a382982-fcfc-48da-b634-474ce906c1c0","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:11","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:12","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.13","description":"file share test"},{"id":"917779ba-cde9-441a-974c-52b557e1c9bc","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.5","description":"file share test"},{"id":"9f4149be-22c9-4425-91b4-f35901490397","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.4","description":"file share test"},{"id":"a641fd61-0b24-4f67-8f69-af4912af97ea","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:40","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:40","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.2","description":"file share test"},{"id":"a8495a47-e80c-4027-9c04-a2d91979438a","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.7","description":"file share test"},{"id":"aea6d04f-ed32-4cb0-afee-036db59cd81d","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:37","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:31:37","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.2","description":"file share test"},{"id":"cf5697a3-42f0-47a7-94a3-fc777a085230","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:11","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:11","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.10","description":"file share test"},{"id":"d3f25a10-d92e-4d34-baa6-cb46415b2467","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:11","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:11","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.12","description":"file share test"},{"id":"d953a48e-e13e-436e-9b4d-23a2e3248524","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:12","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:12","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.14","description":"file share test"},{"id":"ebb20f26-09b7-4d05-8225-5f5891e19d76","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:09","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:09","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.2","description":"file share test"},{"id":"eed1b943-8850-48ae-9731-610d1fae943b","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:09","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:39:09","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.4","description":"file share test"},{"id":"f62424a7-5d06-4cc0-85d3-6d3ccb741cac","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:28","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:29","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.8","description":"file share test"},{"id":"fcdd6f7e-49f2-4dc6-b57a-8aa484486e4b","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:29","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:29","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.9","description":"file share test"},{"id":"ff4e1c87-11a0-4f93-8382-a202df30c853","createdAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:29","updatedAt":"2019-07-04T14:36:29","tenantId":"e93b4c0934da416eb9c8d120c5d04d96","fileshareId":"6ad25d59-a160-45b2-8920-211be282e2df","type":"ip","accessCapability":["Read","Write"],"accessTo":"10.32.104.10","description":"file share test"}]

[jimccfun]

@satya-gorli @Shruthi-1MN can the API support more filter. if it can not be supported now, in dashboard I can make listing in specific order.

[PravinRanjan10]

As per satya comment, if dashboard can list in some order, it would looks good and easy for user. I would recommend if you can list the ACl based on time, it would be good. THanks

[jimccfun]

@PravinRanjan10 Your suggestion is good I will take it, thank you

[satya-gorli]

/assign @jimccfun

[rhsakarpos]

This is a standard issue on UI table data ordering...sharing some guidelines below, followed in another project with a production grade UI, please see if applicable

1. the backend API is totally UI AGNOSTIC. that being said, the backend API must guarantee an order ing (to make it idempotent and deterministic) for any consumer of the API. This order must be published in the API doc.
2. on the UI, any UI component library, will include a table component. This will include a UI model for the column objects. On the table model, the default sorted by column can be set (for on load behavior).
3. Beyond 2 above, each column will have the sort icons (up and down symbols), where the user can select , to sort the table by which column ?
   4 Another issue we had run into, was to handle sorting of IPs, dates etc. They should NOT be lexicographically sorted
4. In case any column has varying units for each row...typically a size column, where some rows are in KB, some are in MB etc, the sorting goes haywire...better to have a single unit for ALL rows in the column
5. if our current UI library does NOT support a rich table model, let us change it. @anvith KS, please weigh in. thanks.
   Just my $0.02.