Spring MVC and AOP: @EnableAspectJAutoProxy needs to be redeclared for each application context [SPR-14753]

[spring-projects-issues]

Manuel Jordan opened SPR-14753 and commented

Hello

According with the following:

• Spring MVC and AOP: @Pointcuts for @Controllers only works in Testing and not for Production

Why the class annotated with @EnableAspectJAutoProxy and scanned through RootApplicationContext is practically ignored by ServletApplicationContext?

Exists two possible solutions:

• the class annotated with @EnableAspectJAutoProxy should be scanned through ServletApplicationContext instead
• the class annotated with @EnableAspectJAutoProxy should be scanned twice, by RootApplicationContext and ServletApplicationContext

I think each approach has a drawback

Furthermore from the current answer:

Seems that BeanFactoryPostProcessor (which is @EnableAspectJAutoProxy in your case) from parent context not applied to child contexts. To make it work in production you must explicitly define @EnableAspectJAutoProxy in child context too

If that is true is it a bug or is the expected behaviour?

Your explanation about this situation with the solution (extra configuration if exists) should be added in the Spring Framework Reference Documentation, it for the rest of the community.

I think here we have a situation about Best Practices

Thanks by your understanding.

---

Affects: 4.3 GA

Reference URL: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/39694633/spring-mvc-and-aop-pointcuts-for-controllers-only-works-in-testing-and-not-fo

Issue Links:

• Doc: Spring AOP dependency on aspectjweaver [SPR-15801] #20356 Doc: Spring AOP dependency on aspectjweaver
• Spring MVC: @EnableScheduling needs to be redeclared for each application context [SPR-16852] #21392 Spring MVC: @EnableScheduling needs to be redeclared for each application context

Referenced from: commits 0e734d8, 13c2134

Backported to: 4.3.15