Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Add Phi_4 provider, Update demo template #2789

Merged
merged 7 commits into from
Mar 10, 2025
Merged

Add Phi_4 provider, Update demo template #2789

merged 7 commits into from
Mar 10, 2025

Conversation

hlohaus
Copy link
Collaborator

@hlohaus hlohaus commented Mar 9, 2025

No description provided.

Copy link

@github-actions github-actions bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Review for Pull Request: Add Phi_4 provider, Update demo template

Thank you, H Lohaus, for contributing to the project! Your addition of the Phi_4 provider and the updates to the demo template are much appreciated.

Summary of Changes

  • Introduced a new provider class Phi_4 in g4f/Provider/hf_space/Phi_4.py.
  • Updated the __init__.py file to include the new Phi_4 provider.
  • Made changes to various files to accommodate the new provider, including updates to image handling and API interactions.

Code Review

Positive Aspects

  • The implementation of the Phi_4 class appears well-structured and follows the existing conventions in the codebase.
  • The use of async functions and proper session management is commendable, ensuring efficient handling of requests.
  • The addition of image handling capabilities is a great enhancement, allowing for more versatile interactions with the API.

Suggestions for Improvement

  • Consider adding docstrings to the methods within the Phi_4 class to improve code readability and maintainability. This will help other developers understand the purpose and usage of each method.
  • It might be beneficial to include some unit tests for the new provider to ensure its functionality and reliability in various scenarios.

Conclusion

Overall, this is a solid addition to the project. Thank you once again for your hard work and dedication. I look forward to seeing this merged and the new capabilities it brings!

Best regards,
[Your Name]

Copy link

github-actions bot commented Mar 9, 2025

Review for Pull Request: Add Phi_4 provider, Update demo template

Thank you, H Lohaus, for contributing to the project! Your work on adding the Phi_4 provider and updating the demo template is greatly appreciated.

Summary of Changes

  • Introduced a new provider Phi_4 in g4f/Provider/hf_space/Phi_4.py.
  • Updated the DeepInfraChat provider to use a new default model.
  • Made adjustments to the demo template and other related files.

Code Review

Positive Aspects

  • The implementation of the Phi_4 provider is well-structured and follows the existing code conventions.
  • The use of async functions and proper session management is commendable.
  • The addition of image handling capabilities enhances the functionality of the provider.

Suggestions for Improvement

  • Consider adding docstrings to the new methods in Phi_4 for better clarity and documentation.
  • It might be beneficial to include some unit tests for the new provider to ensure its reliability and performance.

Minor Comments

  • Ensure that all new files and changes are properly referenced in the documentation to help users understand the new features.

Overall, this is a solid contribution, and I look forward to seeing how it enhances the project. Keep up the great work!

Copy link

Review for Pull Request: Add Phi_4 provider, Update demo template

Summary

Thank you, H Lohaus, for contributing to the project! This pull request introduces the Phi_4 provider and updates the demo template. The changes look promising and will enhance the functionality of our application.

Changes

  1. New Provider:

    • The Phi_4 provider has been added, which supports multimodal capabilities.
    • The implementation appears to be well-structured, utilizing async features effectively.
  2. Code Improvements:

    • The use of format_prompt and format_image_prompt enhances the clarity of the code.
    • The addition of error handling for image uploads is a great touch.
  3. Demo Template Update:

    • The demo template has been updated to reflect the new provider, which is essential for showcasing its capabilities.

Suggestions

  • Consider adding some inline comments in the Phi_4 class to explain the more complex sections of the code for future maintainers.
  • It might be beneficial to include some unit tests for the new provider to ensure its functionality is robust.

Conclusion

Overall, this is a solid addition to the project. I appreciate your hard work and dedication. Looking forward to seeing this merged!

Best,
[Your Name]

Copy link

Pull Request Review by g4f copilot

Thank you, @hlohaus, for contributing to the g4f project. Your pull request introduces several changes and feature additions that aim to enhance the functionality and robustness of the system. Here's my review of your submission:


Pull Request Summary:

Title: Add Phi_4 provider, Update demo template

This pull request introduces the following changes:

  1. Adds a new Phi_4 provider to the g4f.Provider.hf_space ecosystem with support for multimodal input.
  2. Updates the demo template for improved user experience, including styling and handling enhancements.
  3. Implements refinements in utility methods and ensures better type handling for APIs consuming data URIs.
  4. Fixes redundant imports and harmonizes logical flows across updated providers and templates.

Review Notes:

Significant Additions:

1. Phi_4 Provider Implementation

  • A new Phi_4 provider was added under g4f.Provider.hf_space, designed to interface with the microsoft/phi-4-multimodal Hugging Face Space.
  • Implements multimodal capabilities, supporting both text and images as input.
  • Establishes multiple REST endpoint interactions (predict, post, get) for seamless data flow in a conversational context.
  • Includes session/token management leveraging the zerogpu_token system.
Feedback:
  • High Quality: The implementation appears robust, adhering to the project's provider standards.
  • Code Documentation: Excellent inline comments and separation of methods for different endpoints (predict, post, get) make the code readable and maintainable. Good job!

2. Demo Template Update

  • Adjustments in demo.html to better handle iframe and button interactions.
  • Improved error handling for imageFeed adds resilience to the template.
  • Minor style updates (e.g., background handling for images).
Feedback:
  • Usability: The updates enhance user interaction and error recovery. The addition of logical background handling for images demonstrates attention to detail.

3. API Improvements

  • The utilities for handling data URIs (including audio and images) were extended:
    • Introduced is_data_uri_an_media to generalize checks for media types.
    • Refactored is_data_uri_an_image to include validation for audio .wav formats.
  • The create method in the client now accepts string-based messages input, automatically converting them to expected data structures.
Feedback:
  • Integration Ready: The API changes expand input flexibility and media handling. This aligns well with the modular philosophy of the project.

Minor Adjustments:

  • Removed unused imports, such as parent = "HuggingFace", from some modules. This improves code cleanliness.

Suggestions for Further Improvements:

  1. Testing & Validation:

    • Ensure the newly added Phi_4 provider has corresponding tests to validate all its functionalities, such as multimodal API interaction and session management.
  2. Error Messaging:

    • While handling errors (e.g., in Image or Audio validation), consider more user-friendly error messages with actionable insights.
  3. Documentation:

    • It would be helpful to add Phi_4 usage guides (or docstrings) in the README or relevant documentation files since it's a significant new feature.

Actionable Points:

  • Verify end-to-end integration of the Phi_4 provider.
  • Add comprehensive unit tests for the new functionalities introduced.
  • Update documentation to reflect the new addition (Phi_4) and demo UI changes.

Once the above points are addressed, this PR will add significant value to the project and can be merged confidently.


Thank you again, @hlohaus, for the hard work and insightful contributions!

Best regards,
g4f copilot

Copy link

Review for Pull Request: Add Phi_4 provider, Update demo template

Thank you, H Lohaus, for contributing to the project! Your work on adding the Phi_4 provider and updating the demo template is greatly appreciated. Here are my thoughts on the changes:

Summary of Changes

  • New Provider: The addition of the Phi_4 provider looks well-structured and follows the existing conventions in the codebase.
  • Code Quality: The code is clean and well-organized, making it easy to follow the logic. The use of comments and clear method names enhances readability.
  • Functionality: The new methods for handling image uploads and processing prompts are a great addition. They seem to integrate well with the existing functionality.

Suggestions

  • Testing: Ensure that there are adequate tests for the new provider to cover various use cases, especially for the image handling and API interactions.
  • Documentation: It would be beneficial to add some documentation for the new provider, explaining its usage and any specific configurations required.

Conclusion

Overall, this is a solid addition to the project. I look forward to seeing how this enhances the capabilities of our application. Great job!

Keep up the good work!

Copy link

Pull Request Review by g4f Copilot

Author: H Lohaus
Title: Add Phi_4 provider, Update demo template


Summary of Changes

This pull request introduces the following modifications:

  1. Addition of the Phi_4 provider:

    • Implements a new Phi_4 multimodal provider under the hf_space module.
    • Adds support for processing images and videos using the Hugging Face API space.
  2. Enhancements to the demo template:

    • Introduces background changes for better visibility within the demo template.
    • Updates tag filtering for NSFW and other restricted prompts.
  3. Refactoring and Updates:

    • Refactored various APIs to manage responses and handle media (images/audio).
    • Modifications to models across providers for standardization (e.g., updates to Liaobots, AllenAI, PollinationsAI, etc.).
    • Enhanced error handling, normalization for multimedia support, and decoding structure.

Strengths of the Pull Request

  • Complete Implementation: The proposed changes are substantive, introducing multimodal capabilities (audio/image processing) and enhancing template usability.
  • Improved Code Structure: Efforts to unify model aliases and handle uniform image/audio processing across different providers exhibit forward-thinking changes.
  • Fixes: The removal of unused code (e.g., Liaobots’ get_model) contributes to reducing technical debt.

Concerns and Suggestions

  1. Lack of Tests for New Media Handling Logic:

    • While the addition of image/audio functionality is powerful, there are no automated tests for this functionality. Test cases should be created to validate handling edge cases such as invalid formats or corrupted data URIs.
  2. Hardcoded UUID and Tokens:

    • In Phi_4, zerogpu_uuid has a default value of "[object Object]" and manual overrides exist for auth_code. Consider implementing secure dynamic fetches or exposing these via configuration.
  3. Error Handling in Streaming API Integration:

    • While streaming logic uses a robust pattern, the current error case handling in multimedia APIs (e.g., run method of Phi_4) could benefit from more descriptive debug logs or standardized error outputs for easier troubleshooting.
  4. Code Style Consistency:

    • The addition of is_data_an_wav and checking file formats is helpful; however, this logic could possibly break for a broader set of formats. Suggest reviewing binary format checks and consolidating them into a generic utility.

Recommendations for Action

  • Add unit tests for classes such as Phi_4 and ensure image/audio prompts and multimedia are handled robustly.
  • Improve documentation, especially for new functionalities (responses, multimedia handling, etc.).
  • Replace sensitive defaults with environment variables or configuration files.

Verdict

The pull request adds significant improvements and functionalities to the project. While there are minor points for improvement, the contributions overall align with the project's goals and will expand its capabilities.


Thank you, H Lohaus, for contributing to the project! Your work in expanding support for multimodal providers and refining code quality is greatly appreciated. Looking forward to your continued contributions!

Copy link

Pull Request Review

Author: H Lohaus
Title: Add Phi_4 provider, Update demo template


Summary:

This pull request introduces the following changes:

  1. New Provider: Adds a new Hugging Face Space provider Phi_4 for multimodal capabilities (hf_space/Phi_4.py).
  2. Updates to Provider Registry: Updates the Hugging Space provider list to include the Phi_4 provider.
  3. Demo Template Updates: Makes adjustments to the demo HTML and JavaScript for improved functionality, including handling multimedia content and refining certain UI/UX aspects (demo.html, chat.v1.js).
  4. Helper Enhancements: Improves helper functions to handle media (images and WAV files) in a more robust way (image/__init__.py).
  5. Bug Fixes: Fixes a range of issues, such as properly handling tokens, addressing content-type mismatches, and improving generator behavior.

Strengths:

  • Phi_4 Implementation: The new provider uses Hugging Face APIs effectively, showcasing a structured initialization process for session tokens, conversation handling, and multimedia support (text and images).
  • Media Functionality: Expands functionality to support both image and WAV audio formats with improved validation and handling features in g4f/image/__init__.py.
  • Refactor & Cleanup: Removes unused or redundant code (e.g., get_model in Liaobots.py), which improves maintainability.
  • Demo Improvements: Changes to the demo template and JavaScript offer clearer behavior, such as handling edge cases for malformed inputs and streamlining the usage metrics calculation.

Potential Issues:

  1. Error Handling in Phi_4:

    • The run method in Phi_4.py appears to pass the prompt and images to the API, but limited error handling is present for edge cases (e.g., if the API response lacks expected keys).
    • Consider including explicit logging or fallback mechanisms to handle unexpected API responses or session initialization failures.
  2. Session Management:

    • Session tokens (zerogpu_token, zerogpu_uuid) are managed and updated dynamically, but there's a risk of inconsistency if the provider returns invalid or expired tokens mid-session.
    • Including retry logic or token refresh mechanisms could improve robustness.
  3. Hardcoded Strings:

    • Strings like "microsoft/phi-4-multimodal", "predict", and "post" are often referenced directly.
    • Consider using constants for such values to ensure easier maintenance and better code readability.
  4. Unused Imports:

    • There seem to be a few unused imports (e.g., Cookies in hf_space/Phi_4.py). These should be reviewed and removed where not necessary.
  5. Demo Template Restrictions:

    • The current demo template implements a hardcoded list of blocked tags for prompt input. While useful, this approach might lead to over-blocking or user confusion if more nuanced filtering is required.
    • Suggest documenting these restrictions or offering dynamic tagging adjustments.
  6. Backwards Compatibility Risk:

    • Certain changes in the client/__init__.py and response.py (e.g., YouTube and Audio response handling updates) might break compatibility with previously dependent features. Ensure integration tests confirm these changes don't introduce regressions.

Recommendations for Improvement:

  1. Add unit tests for new functions and methods, especially for Phi_4's run and create_async_generator.
  2. Improve demo user experience by providing feedback in case the user's input matches banned tags in the template.
  3. Add comments or docstrings where logic or flows are complex, e.g., session initialization in Phi_4.
  4. Consider introducing centralized logging for better debugging across providers and the GUI backend.

Approval Status:

This pull request is well-done and introduces a powerful new provider alongside various fixes and improvements. Minor refinements and additional testing are recommended, but the overall quality is solid.
Approved with Suggestions


Thank you, H Lohaus, for your contribution to the project! Your implementation of the Phi_4 provider and related updates greatly enhance the codebase's functionality.

@hlohaus hlohaus merged commit 8a57323 into main Mar 10, 2025
3 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant