-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 975
disable webusb API #13374
Comments
we actually don't support bluetooth yet AFAIK. https://googlechrome.github.io/samples/web-bluetooth/device-info.html?allDevices=true fails without showing a prompt in Brave. |
fix #13374 Test Plan: automated tests for content loading should pass
Hello I am a developer of Trezor - a cryptocurrency hardware wallet - and in next iteration of our products, we will support WebUSB. I have tested WebUSB version of Trezor, and WebUSB doesn't actualy work in Brave. (Tested on Linux.)
Our web wallet detects whether webusb is defined via navigator.usb, if it is not defined, we offer user to install a local server which browser then connects to. Anyway, this detection is broken in Brave - navigator.usb is defined, yet So please, either disable it (by setting navigator.usb to null) or fix it. Right now, webUSB is enabled, but broken. Which is actually good security-wise (nobody can access any device anyway), but bad from web developer point of view. (Btw - here is the public Chrome issue that deals with this - Google's solution is just blacklist the yubikey IDs. This is working to patch the bug, but not fixes the underlying issue, which would be fixable by at least optional descriptors, as I noted there and on the webusb github WICG/webusb#127 ) |
I would personally prefer if the webusb was enabled, but the descriptor rules enforced :) which would fix this, as the yubikey devices definitely don't have the webusb descriptors. But that would require changes probably beyond the scope of Brave |
@karel-3d as you can see in #13375 it's going to be disabled for now |
Hm, this seems that navigator.usb is still defined, but the function returns rejecting promise. This is not ideal :/ as it requires special casing |
@karel-3d good point. i think i can set them to undefined |
Thanks, this will help! When Chrome recently (today) kill-switched webusb remotely, it set navigator.usb to undefined |
neither are supported, but this will cause sites that check whether they're supported to know more reliably that they aren't supproted. fix #13374 Test Plan: 1. go to any site and open page console. 2. navigator.usb should be undefined 3. navigator.bluetooth should be undefined
#13375 updated |
Verified on macOS 10.12.6 x64 using the following build:
Verified on Windows 7 x64
Verified on Ubuntu 17.10 x64 using the following build:
|
Test plan
See #13375
Original issue description
webusb can be used to bypass yubikey phishing protection at the moment: https://www.wired.com/story/chrome-yubikey-phishing-webusb/ -> we should disable navigator.usb
@flamsmark also suggested disabling navigator.bluetooth
maybe also https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Navigator/sendBeacon ?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: