Please close this issue. I do not want to be further associated with it.

[maxidorius]

Retired

[her001]

#2349 also describes a spec violation.

room_id missing from response body for rooms/{roomId}/join endpoint

This is client-server and present in both stable and unstable. I have an open PR to fix it.

[maxidorius]

@her001 Thank you, added to the list

[jplatte]

#2349 was fixed in #2986, with the fix being released in v0.27.3. Maybe you could convert the list to a task list so you can tick it off :)

[maxidorius]

@jplatte thank you for bringing it up. Sadly I don't have time to keep this up-to-date, so I'll close it as it's outdated on several issues and new ones are not listed.

[ara4n]

reopening as it's useful for us to track, even if bits are stale.

[uhoreg]

ma1uta has also started a list at https://github.com/ma1uta/jeon/blob/master/SpecDiff.md

[Half-Shot]

Given we have lost the content forever, I guess this can be closed now? :(

[ara4n]

The other content in the comments is still useful, as was the original post, which I'm hoping @maxidor will restore rather than being obstructive.

[turt2live]

Here's all the references I could find:

• Enforce Server-Server 4.1 PDU fields #3162
• Add room_id to the response of rooms/{roomId}/join #2986
• Synapse creates invalid rooms as per stable/unstable spec #2644
• Federation event format returns a client event format #2604
• Incorrect HTTP Status returned on unknown/invalid access token #2602
• room_id missing from response body for rooms/{roomId}/join endpoint #2349

[turt2live]

References from matrix-doc:

• (Attempt to) Fix event authorization rules to allow first Power Levels events to be injected in the room matrix-spec-proposals#1052
• Add status for unknown user's filter ID matrix-spec-proposals#1045

[maxidorius]

Could you please make another issue and close this one? People keep contacting me about it and I'm really not interested in further discussing this.

[turt2live]

Closing in favour of #3506 - thanks for recording the original list @maxidor.