Interoperability Project Management

[tynes]

This is a tracking discussion for updates on the development of the interop project.

Contributing

The interop specs serve as the source of truth for what is being built. The specs should be written before any implementations are merged and should be used to drive code review. Longer form discussions exist for async communications about the project.

There are 3 standups per week: Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. Notes are kept here. The Monday standup is required and all teams should provide a status update to share with the rest of the team about their work stream.

The design-docs repository should be used to build consensus on designs. Please follow the guidelines in the design docs repo's README.

It is up to the discretion of the engineers to decide what should be turned into a design doc vs a spec. Some features should be a design doc first and then turned into a spec while others only need one of the two.

Meetings

A new comment should be created each week that includes status updates from each owner of a project. Further discussion about that week should be done in sub comments.

The following templates can be used:

# Kickoff MM/DD/YYYY
## Goals
- ...
## Project Updates

### Project 1
- ...

Resources

• Project Board
• Discussion Q&A

[tynes]

Kickoff 06/17/2024

Goals

• Scope devnet 1 milestone
• Onboard @ajsutton and @Inphi to the client workstream
• Make progress on interoperable ether design - design-doc: interoperable ether design-docs#25

Discussion

• Time for meetings?
• Cutting Scope!
  • Can we descope deposits triggering executing messages completely from the initial release? Just ship this initial design
  • Working on GovToken scoping, may need to cut from initial release unless we can make fast progress on it

Project Updates

Interop Go updates:

op-supervisor

Adrian implemented a draft of the supervisor DB, with support for initiating messages:
See: #10902

Proto reviewed, and Adrian started on executing messages support.
Draft here: #10973

Proto will re-review latest changes today or Monday.

Deriver refactor

Making solid progress on refactor of
op-node driver/derivation components to become event-based, incrementally.
Tracking issue: #10865

3 stacked in-flight PRs.
Some of these may need minor updates for tests still, reviewing that today.
The last PR is draft, almost done, finalization code testing update is in progress.

After that a bit more polishing remains, to cut out the last shared state in the op-node driver,
and go towards fully event-based processing.
The main question is whether or not we include the sequencing also.
This is a bit of extra scope, but makes the engine separation a lot better,
by not having shared synchronous engine-controller state anywhere anymore.
Given the devnet timeline change, Proto will implement this early next week.

And then next week we can lift the events processing into parallel processing (by running each deriver in a separate go routine).
See: #10864

Deposits tx

Proto proposed, largely based on inputs from others during cowork day,
there is a two-step way to get to a usable form of interop usage through deposit txs.
The first step is sufficient for devnet 1, and prepares us for the next.

See #10867

Mofi has started onboarding as part-time contributor and may implement
this deposit derivation and CrossL2Inbox change.

Devnet 1 timing

The above issues all have to be closed out first,
and more work remains to complete the op-supervisor MVP and integration
of the safety-checking into op-node. This will be started next week,
but is going to continue after collective-pause. This puts the devnet target at mid July.

Superc20 updates:

SuperchainERC20 Standard

We have completed the initial prototype, which includes ideas for 'xAllowances' and 'remoteTransferFrom' functions. https://defi-wonderland.notion.site/WIP-Superc20-code-276a3aa14c054c08a1eebbf9ec0d4696

Currently, we are working on expanding this in order to send a formal Design Doc/PR very soon.

Liquidity Migration

We have published three new design documents to enable migration, making existing tokens interoperable:

• Liquidity Migration: Discussing potential approaches for Liquidity Migration from L2 tokens locked in L1 using the current OptimismMintableERC20 Factory. We have outlined why Mirror Design is one of the most suitable path. design-doc: liquidity migration design-docs#35
• Mirror Standard: expanding in how the Mirror approach should look like design-doc: mirror standard design-docs#36
• Limited space Mirror Factory: describing a potential design for a new factory capable of deploying Mirror contracts for OptimismMintableERC20Tokens. feat: adding limited space mirror factory design-docs#37

[tynes]

Kickoff 06/24/2024

Goals

• Make decisions on the SuperchainERC20 designs Design Review: 6/25/2024 design-docs#38
• Start implementing design-doc: interoperable ether design-docs#25
• Progress towards devnet 1

Project Updates

Interop Client (Go work) updates:

Deriver refactor

Since last update, landed:

• op-program events Interop: encapsulate op-program claim validation #10959
• AttributesHandler events Interop: Event-handling update of AttributesHandler #10852
• Finalizer events Interop: Event-handling update of Finalizer #10851

Proto working on:

• Sequencer events Interop: update sequencer to events deriver #10979 (draft PR: op-node: sequencing better encapsulated, now with events #10991 )
• Tomorrow: Polish of driver, wrap up events usage: Interop: Event-handling polishing of Driver #10850
• This week: lifting events handling to parallel deriver execution.

op-supervisor

• Adrian implemented op-supervisor logdb improvements. op-supervisor: Add log db #10902
• Adrian added op-supervisor docker/CI. op-supervisor: Add op-supervisor build to CI #10985
• Adrian working on more of the logdb execution-message functionality. Record executing messages in log db and handle write failures #10973
• Proto reviewing/merging above today.

deposit-tx handling

• No updates here, tracking issue: Interop: Ban Deposits that Trigger Executing Messages for Devnet #10867

Superc20 updates:

SuperchainERC20 Standard

We're about to make a PR on PR 71 that covers most of the required topics. Also, we'll focus on the xERC20 spike over the new standard.

Liquidity Migration

We have made small updates to the Mirror Factory Design Doc and have been discussing the Liquidity Migration and Mirror docs (see above). This week, we will discuss our designs (on Tuesday), and then we will move on to the specs.

DevX

• DevX team agreed on P0 initial project: "supersim" local development environment that simulates interop
• Draft design document available
• Project kickoff today, follow along here

[tynes]

Client Work

Proto (op-node deriver work):

Current:

• Merged sync-status event handling: op-node: maintain sync-status through events, remove legacy snapshot-log #11008
• Work in progress sequencer event handling: op-node: sequencing better encapsulated, now with events #10991
  Next: Some polish / test util improvements remain:
• Interop: Event-handling polishing of Driver #10850
• Interop: event handling utils and syntax sugar #10983

Adrian (op-supervisor work):

Current:

• op-supervisor DB was merged
• op-supervisor events watching / fetching: op-supervisor: Create clients and monitor chain heads for each L2 chain #11009
  Next:
• continue op-supervisor events fetching work
• cross-L2 dependency safety resolution using the filled DB

Mofi (deposit-tx work):

Current:

• Specs PR in review: interop: Specify deposit handling specs#258
  Next:
• Get specs PR landed
• Deposit context support in L1Block predeploy

Superc20 updates:

SuperchainERC20 Standard

At Wonderland we have made our first PR on top of PR 71 and are now simplifying the current proposed interface design, as suggested by @tynes ​​and @smartcontracts. We are also adding more details and addressing other comments. ethereum-optimism/specs#257

This Friday, we will present SuperchainERC20 to the reviewers. ethereum-optimism/design-docs#42

Liquidity Migration

Following the call referenced in ethereum-optimism/design-docs#38, we have decided not to proceed with the Mirror standard. Instead, we will move into the Convert solution, initially specified here ethereum-optimism/design-docs#35. We will work on presenting a detailed Design Doc for the Convert solution.

[tynes]

Interop Go client update:

Derivers: (Proto)

• general events improvements and fix of hot loop: op-node: fix driver step hot loop, improve events and add utils #11040
• sequencer PR still in progress, but passing a lot more tests already: op-node: sequencing better encapsulated, now with events #10991
• slow today, light food poisoning

op-supervisor: (Adrian)

• Create log DB for each chain: op-supervisor: Create logdb for each chain #11043
• Write logs to logdb: op-supervisor: Write logs to logdb #11046

deposit-tx: (Mofi)

• refining the specs, see interop: Specify deposit handling specs#258 (comment)

Superc20 updates:

SuperchainERC20 Standard

At Wonderland we have updated our SuperchainERC20 standard PR, adding invariants, future considerations, and addressing comments. ethereum-optimism/specs#257

Importantly, today we have presented our advances around SuperchainERC20 and Factory design paterns to the reviewers. ethereum-optimism/design-docs#42

Liquidity Migration

As we talked last Wednesday, we are currently working on the Convert solution and crafting a Design Doc around this approach.

Superchain WETH

SuperchainWETH is built on top of the SuperchainERC20 spec, since the standard hasn't been finalized yet, its a draft PR. Design goal to make it as simple as possible, no auto unwrapping to prevent footguns.

• feat: introduce SuperchainWETH and ETHLiquidity #11042

[tynes]

Kickoff 07/08/2024

Goals

• Make progress on the devnet 1 milestone
  • When devnet 1? There is a good chunk of work. Likely 2 weeks minimum
• Make progress on SuperchainERC20 design
• Make progress on GovToken

Project Updates

Client

We are resuming from a week of pause.
This week we are wrapping up the events refactor, getting MVP op-supervisor, and working on integrating the two.
Main target: get op-supervisor with op-node running in op-e2e, to prepare us for devnet.
Devnet will likely take at least till end next week.

deriver (events refactor), Proto:

• 4 PRs in progress (drafts opening today):
  • event.System introduction (organize events, support tracing, prepare for parallel execution)
  • Parallel event executor
  • Event trace diagrams
  • Event based engine/sequencer
• Goal is to land the above, and start on cross-unsafe label integration between op-node/op-geth

op-supervisor, Adrian:

• write event-logs to DB: op-supervisor: Write logs to logdb #11046
• chainID (typing improvements): op-supervisor: Introduce ChainID type. #11088
• Need to revisit op-supervisor issue tracking: many issues open, we need to narrow down scope for MVP devnet

deposit-tx, Mofi:

• Specs in progress: interop: Specify deposit handling specs#258
• Need to start implementation, of MVP solution, for devnet
• Multi-threaded cannon work is ongoing still

Source of truth for communicating with devinfra: https://github.com/ethereum-optimism/devinfra-pod/issues/165

Governance

• Alligator specs revamped and ready for review: governance: create GovernanceDelegation specs specs#247
• Continue development of GovToken based on its specs.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

SuperchainERC20 Standard specs

We continue updating our PR on SuperchainERC20 Standard specs:

• Now spec presentation follows standard formats.
• sendERC20 and relayERC20 functions and events, including a mermaid diagram, are updated.
• SuperchainERC20 invariants are updated.

The latest version is available for reviews: ethereum-optimism/specs#257

SuperchainERC20 Standard development

We have started onboard our solidity dev team into the project.

Liquidity Migration

We have worked extensively on design approaches around the Convert solution, and we have opened a new thread into the interop-evm Discord channel, discussing isolated vs. unified approaches. Next step is to make our design doc public.

[tynes]

Kickoff 07/17/2024

Project Updates

Client Work

Quick mid-week Interop client Go update:

Devnet 1 timeline is slipping:

• Significant integration work left to do still. Doc in progress describing this in more detail.
• Deposit-tx work-around for devnet 1 not implemented yet.
• E2E testing in progress, not ready yet.
• Adrian/Mofi pulled onto fault-proof related work (and Proto briefly too).

Deriver-refactor: done, deployed on Sepolia devnet, being tested in regular release flow.

Supervisor: integration time, working on RPC endpoints and automated safety progression to update heads data.

Deposit-tx interop work: no progress.

SuperchainERC20

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

SuperchainERC20 Standard specs

Our latest commit has been merged into specs repo. ethereum-optimism/specs#268

Superchain ERC20 development

We have started the development of the initial implementation of the SuperchainERC20 contract and Factory.

Liquidity Migration

Today we had a design review session, and the convert-unified has been the selected as the design path to go forward. ethereum-optimism/design-docs#46

Now we're gonna start with the work on specs, breaking them into two separate projects: the convert solution itself and the registry for legacy token authenticity.

SuperchainERC20 Factory specs

We're making great progress on the SuperchainERC20 Factory Design Doc. We plan to publish it by EOW.

GovToken

Governance (Agora + Diego) updates:

GovernanceToken: Implementation

Working on last implementation details at #11168, aiming to be ready for review EOD.

Alligator: Specs

Resolved last review comments and ready for another iteration: ethereum-optimism/specs#247

Alligator: Implementation

Contract and predeploy setup in progress, aiming to be ready for review tommorow: #11167

[tynes]

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Superchain ERC20 development

We have come up with an initial version of SuperchainERC20 standard and Factory contracts. It's private for now and subject to any change. We're about to do unit tests and settle some decisions to go forward into first deployments and further tests.

Liquidity Migration

We're working on specs for convert approach and the needed registry. Also we're starting discussion on ideas of potential designs to solve migration for existing L2 native tokens and custom bridged tokens.

SuperchainERC20 Factory specs

We've presented the design doc for the Factory. Note that design details how it would work for L1 native tokens in line with our work on liquidity migration. However, most of the design described can be ported to factories for L2 native tokens.

Please read here: ethereum-optimism/design-docs#50

Interop Go update:

• With additional FP work, integration challenges, and deposit-tx delays, we will not be ready for Devnet 1 next week.
• Proto and Adrian are working on op-node/op-supervisor integration. Design-doc here: op-supervisor-integration design-docs#49
• Proto working on op-e2e test setup for interop. Publishing reorganized but backwards-compatible deploy-config PR today.
• Adrian and Mofi will be assumed to only contribute review-only capacity temporarily.
• Proto is on-call next week.

[tynes]

Kickoff 07/22/2024

Goals

• Figure out devnet release

Project Updates

Interop DevX Update:

• We are wrapping up stage 0 of Supersim, allowing devs to run multiple anvil nodes locally with one command. Work has begun on Stage 1, simulating interop functionality.
• We have a PRD ready for interop abstractions (viem actions and wagmi hooks), and will begin work on it this week.
• Tic Tac Toe reference implementation is working with Supersim but will benefit from the abstractions work.
• Working on Supersim GTM plan and reference implementation ideas.

Go Interop update:

• Open design doc on op-supervisor integration: op-supervisor-integration design-docs#49
  • Received reviews from Adrian and Mark.
  • Proto to address review comments and continue on implementation draft + API specs.
• GitHub interop devnet issues require some updates, to reflect latest op-supervisor <> op-node integration ideas.
• Adrian and Mofi at least part-time on FP, mostly contributing in review capacity for now.
• Proto is on-call.
• op-e2e improvements to facilitate interop in progress:
  • op-chain-ops: Organize deploy-config, improve check-logging #11189
  • Interop-ready Go e2e test setup #11180

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Superchain ERC20 development

Continuing in the progress of initial version of SuperchainERC20 standard and Factory contracts.

Liquidity Migration

We continue making progress on the specs for convert approach and the needed registry. We plan to make a first PR this week.

We started to work with other token cases to complete the TVL coverage.

SuperchainERC20 Factory specs

We will make some changes regarding SuperchainERC20, most notably to make possible token deployments on L2 and conserving underlying token properties properly.

ethereum-optimism/design-docs#50

Governance (Agora) updates:

GovernanceToken: Implementation

GovernaceToken ready for review at #11167, decoupling to be easily reviewed.

Alligator: Specs

Working on resolving last comments from review at ethereum-optimism/specs#247

Alligator: Implementation

Working on fuzz and unit tests for Alligator contract at #11167

[tynes]

Governance (Agora) updates:

GovernanceToken & Alligator: Implementation

Updated Alligator to match latest changes on spec (specifically, add logic for readjusting voting power after token transfers) and updated GovToken based on Alligator changes: #11167

Alligator: Specs

Working on resolving last comments from review at ethereum-optimism/specs#247

Added new sections to specify the calculation of voting power for absolute and relative delegations.

GovernanceToken interop: specs

Opened PR, building on top of Alligator specs: ethereum-optimism/specs#285

Quick mid-week Go interop update:

• Adrian part-time on interop, part-time FP:
  • reviewing op-node <> op-supervisor design doc: op-supervisor-integration design-docs#49
  • lifting API from design doc into specs draft
• Proto working on interop testing:
  • Design-doc to approach chain-deployments different, such that we can run two customized L2s with shared L1:
    deployment-chains: Idea to resolve deployment composition and customization design-docs#52
• Mofi continues to work on FP stack for now

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Superchain ERC20 development

Working on the convert-specific SuperchainERC20 contract and its tests to submit a PR this week.

Liquidity Migration

We made our first PR for Liquidity migrations specs, underlying how the conversion mechanism would work. ethereum-optimism/specs#294

SuperchainERC20 Factory specs

Working on solving some comments and making a few updates to the doc.

ethereum-optimism/design-docs#50

[tynes]

Go Interop update

Interop testing (Proto)

• deployment-chains: Idea to resolve deployment composition and customization design-docs#52: We are resolving Chain test-setup/config tech-debt,
  see proposal. So far there is positive feedback from @tynes and @mds1.
• Chain-deploys: implement caching part MVP #11253: Getting started on a more minimal proof of concept.
  Supervisor integration (Adrian)
• op-supervisor-integration design-docs#49: Completed initial desing-doc review.
• interop: Add initial indexing api spec specs#283: Opened specs PR for RPC of op-supervisor, needs review from Proto.

Governance (Agora) updates:

GovernanceToken & Alligator: Implementation

Finished testing GovernanceToken migration logic, now testing Alligator: #11167

Alligator: Specs

Working on gas griefing issue for token transfers, and resolving comments from last review ethereum-optimism/specs#247

GovernanceToken interop: specs/design

Going back to the design phase for the approach @smartcontracts shared for cross-chain delegations.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

SuperchainERC20 Specs RelayERC20 Event Parameters

Created and moved to in review.

Created the PR to include the suggested change of the SuperchainERC20 RelayERC20 event to also include the source chain id as well as the msg.sender of the sendERC20 function.

OptimismSuperchainERC20 Implementation

Still in progress.

Logic is ready. Unit tests are ready. Will push the PR today. We are also working on adding invariant tests to it.

SuperchainERC20: Migrated Liquidity (Convert) Spec

Moved to in review.

First iteration has been posted. Feedback has been posted by the reviewers addressed. It's ready for another review pass.

SuperchainERC20: Liquidity Migration token research

Created and moved to in progress.

We have shared one doc exploring how to handle custom tokens cases. Additionally, we did a simple list characterizing the existing tokens bridged via StandardBridge, focusing on the implementation and deployment method used.

SuperchainERC20: Factory Design Doc

Moved to in review.

Working on solving comments and making the relevant updates to prepare it for a second iteration of reviews.

[tynes]

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

SuperchainERC20 Specs RelayERC20 Event Parameters

Reviewed and completed

Spec has been merged.

OptimismSuperchainERC20 Implementation

Still in progress.

Working on implementing the contract using the initializable pattern and employing unstructured storage.

SuperchainERC20: Migrated Liquidity (Convert) Spec

Still in review.

Every comment was addressed on the PR. It was approved, but still not merged.

SuperchainERC20: Liquidity Migration token research

Still in progress.

We are continuing our discussions in the channel on how the token list/registry should function and which tokens are safe to include, taking all considerations into account.

SuperchainERC20: Factory Design Doc

Still in review.

We have updated the design doc to remove L1 initialization. We are currently discussing the PR. As soon as we resolve everything, we will start working on the specs.

GovToken

Governance (Agora) updates:

GovernanceDelegation Specs

Resolved comments from review and merged.

GovernanceDelegation & GovernanceTokenInterop implementation

Still in progress.

Resolved comments from last review -- revamped token to inherit GovernanceToken and upgraded GovernanceDelegation to 0.8.25. Continuing to test and trying to reduce implementation complexity.

Interoperable OP Design Doc

In review.

Under review, with design review meeting tomorrow (August 1st)

Client

Quick mid-week Go update:

• Adrian and Mofi fully occupied with Fault Proof work
• Onboarding Axel to op-supervisor verification tasks
• Proto working on op-e2e test tooling for interop
  • Deploy-chain genesis generation MVP #11281
    65f2d84c663947e88acfdb7a3023e91b
• Axel Onboarded with Proto Monday/Yesterday
• Went over supervisor<>node interactions
• Built a document to go over the behavior cases and get confidence on the design (https://oplabs.notion.site/Interop-Reasoning-about-Cross-Safety-Management-and-Reorgs-65f2d84c663947e88acfdb7a3023e91b)

[fainashalts]

DevX Updates

Supersim Stage 0 complete

• Can use supersim to spin up and manage multiple anvil nodes.
• Demo on Friday.

Supersim Stage 1 in progress

• working on intercepting & simulating interop messages.
• Also scoping out asset transfer work.
• Repo: https://github.com/ethereum-optimism/supersim

Abstractions work is under way: viem is done, just working on docs. wagmi work next.

• Repo: https://github.com/ethereum-optimism/ecosystem/tree/d2dbdb46eb3bcaa4710e40d86fad5a8afbd7f727/packages/viem

Supersim design

• Needs some updates post review, will try to finish it this week and get approval to merge.

Tic Tac Toe reference implementation

• Done for now.
• Will be updated to use interop abstractions.

Working through next steps

• Sidecars for Supersim for UX improvements (relayers, AA, etc.)
• Reference implementations
• GTM approach

[tynes]

Interop Go update:

• Proto and Axel revised Devnet 1 tickets:
  • Devnet 1 tickets
• Axel continuing work on op-supervisor:
  • Implementation work to continue
  • Writing a doc that walks through the safety-resolution edge cases.
• Proto rebased local devnet draft of jinmel, and will implement some remaining improvements:
  • Ticket PR draft
• Working on unblocking op-e2e chain deployment, and some monorepo cleanup of contracts-bedrock toolchain.

Interop-EVM (Wonderland) updates:

ValidateMessage

Moved to In Review

This task was completed by @tynes yesterday here: #11322. He frontran us. Very fast.

ExecutingMessage Parameter Change

Moved to Done

This was merged yesterday: ethereum-optimism/specs#254

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

SuperchainERC20 Event Tense Change

Still In Review

Small PR aimed to change the tense of the events emitted by the SuperchainERC20 to past tense in order to match other contract's.

OptimismSuperchainERC20 Implementation

Still in progress.

Contract now follows the initializable pattern and uses unstructured storage. A small interface change will be pushed today now that SuperchainWETH has been merged, but the main functionality is already there and ready to be reviewed again.

Convert Implementation

Moving to in progress by Monday

We were going to start with this one yesterday but we did some internal reorganization and this will be starting on Monday.

SuperchainERC20: Migrated Liquidity (Convert) Spec

Moved to Done

PR was merged to main.

SuperchainERC20: Liquidity Migration token research

Still in progress.

We have shared a new document in how L2 native tokens would be included into the liquidity migration scope. Additionally, we're working in another document outlining how to move forward to come up with the list of token enabled to be compatible with convert.

SuperchainERC20: Factory Design Doc

Still in review.

It's ready for Review. We will schedule a session for next week.

Update OptimismMintableERC20Factory specs

Created the card

Will start working on this next week.

Agora

• Taking feedback on interop design for governance
• Going to publish design for Governor
• Doing some UX research on multichain voting

[tynes]

Kickoff 08/05/2024

Goals

• Plan rigorously for devnet 1 launch
• Onboard @AmadiMichael
• Specify Governor
• Continue progress on SuperchainERC20 line of work
• Hone in on time estimates

Interop Go updates

Local devnet

Work in progress. Draft by Proto: #11324
This is being prioritized due to blockers on op-e2e.

op-e2e testing

Currently blocked by minimal DeployConfig modularization work on the forge deploy scripts side.

After that, for proper integration with unblocked path for full coverage into op-e2e,
we need to improve how op-e2e configures and creates deployments.

We still have an open design doc for cache-based integration of the deploy scripts into op-e2e: ethereum-optimism/design-docs#52

This may however be replaced with a newer alternative idea of running the Forge scripts in Go, to avoid caching complexity. Tracked here: #11360
We should reschedule the design-doc review of the first proposal, so we can take this new proposed solution into account.

op-supervisor

Axel was OOO this morning. Next work continues on #11311

After indexing the executing messages correctly we can proceed
with dependency resolution and
API responses.

Communication

Proto created slides for a quick technical overview of the message passing part of Interop.
This is now being extended to full interop scope by the team.
With some more work this might turn into a good interop-tech introduction doc.

Extra Detail From Axel:

• First focusing on updating and merging Adrain's old "include executing message data" PR to use the Hashes.

• Next focused on using the Head Database when responding to API queries

• Two more tickets exist beyond that which I'm not ready to commit to just yet

• Also digging deeper on the way Nodes:Supervisor must track potentially invalid blocks w/ Adrian, using the reasoning doc I made last week. We've got a little more clarity that we've got a reorg-compatible solution, and I think some new observations about interop:FP requirements.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• OptimismSuperchainERC20 Implementation

  In Review
  Ready to be reviewed again. Link to PR

• Convert Implementation

  In Progress
  We created the first implementation in our public repo and will submit a PR to the Optimism repo once we review it in our repo: feat: liquidity migration defi-wonderland/optimism#10

Design Doc and Specs

• SuperchainERC20 Event Tense Change

  Still In Review
  Ready for any other required reviews before merging.

• SuperchainERC20: Factory Design Doc

  Still in review.
  It's ready for Review. We need to schedule a review meeting.

• Update OptimismMintableERC20Factory specs

  In Progress
  PR was opened. Link to PR

Governance (Agora) updates:

Implementation

• Advance delegation implementation

  In progress
  Finished unit and fuzz tests. Working on reducing complexity for GovernanceDelegation. Link to PR

Design Doc and Specs

• Governor specs

  In progress
  Aiming to be ready for review by EOD. Link to PR

• Governor Interop Design Doc

  TODO
  Next item after interop design doc.

• GovernanceDelegation interop design doc

  Updating based on last review
  Resolving comments and feedback from last review meeting. Ready for another review soon (EOD). Link to PR

[tynes]

Interop (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• Ban Deposits

  Still In Progress

  All feedback has been addressed. We are waiting for one more review while continuing work on the smart contracts and client tests.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• OptimismSuperchainERC20 Implementation

  Still In Review

  Ready to be reviewed again. Link to PR

• Convert Implementation

  Still In Progress

  Added the unit tests to our public repository: test: add L2 standard bridge interop unit tests defi-wonderland/optimism#13

  Added a generic interface to factories in our public repository: fix: add generic factory interface defi-wonderland/optimism#14

  We will submit a pull request to the Optimism repository once we have reviewed it in our end.

Design Doc and Specs

• SuperchainERC20 Event Tense Change

  Still In Review

  Ready for any other required reviews before merging.

• SuperchainERC20: Factory Design Doc

  Still in review.

  We just had the review meeting. We will address the feedback and begin working on the specs.

• Update OptimismMintableERC20Factory specs

  In Progress

  We are discussing details in the PR here

Research

• SuperchainERC20: Liquidity Migration token research

  Still In Progress

  We have scheduled a meeting with Zain and Kevin for tomorrow in order to discuss how to move forward with the token list for the registry. A pre-read will be shared very soon.

Go updates:

Interop test setup / deploy Flow

Design-docs by @protolambda and @mds1 are scheduled for a review meeting tomorrow.

The proposed Go test-setup depends on functionality of op-geth that has changed a lot in March.
These updates still need to be pulled into op-geth.
There is a draft of the op-geth updates
by the Base team, which Proto will help review.

The draft of a local devnet is still open,
and while ready for some review, some of the configuration steps are incomplete.
This is blocked until we have some of the configuration improvements that are part of OPStackManager milestone 1.
We can maybe hack around it if needed, but the focus is on doing things the right way: write maintainable tests.

Deposit tx handling in Interop

We reviewed the draft PR by Skeletor.

op-supervisor

Axel is making progress on implementation, we debugged some ABI-decoding quirks,
and now the PR to decode executing message events
is review for review.

Axel Update:
Won't be able to make standup today, but I just now got the Executing Message Decoding/Inclusion working. Not sure all tests will pass but opened it for review anyway:
#11369

Governance (Agora) updates:

Implementation

• Advance delegation implementation

  In progress
  Compacted and reduced checkpoint aggregation logic. Working on remaining gas improvements. Link to PR

Design Doc and Specs

• Governor specs

  Ready for review
  Ready for review. Link to PR

• Governor Interop Design Doc

  In progress
  Documenting changes required for the Governor to support GovernanceDelegation interop design. Opening PR EOD.

• GovernanceDelegation interop design doc

  Ready for review
  Ready for design meeting on Monday. Link to PR

[Joxess]

Interop (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• Ban Deposits - Still In Progress

  The smart contract work is complete. Client-side work is ongoing, including fixes, improvements, tests, and natspecs. We plan to submit a non-draft PR by mid or end of next week.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• OptimismSuperchainERC20 Implementation - Still In Review

  Improved Invariant Tests. Link to PR.
  The implementation is ready for another review. Link to PR.

• Convert Implementation - Still In Progress

  Working on more expected modifications in this PR.

• Interop: Update OptimismMintableERC20Factory Implementation - Created the task and moved to In Progress

  We've added modifications to the OptimismMintableERC20Factory in our public repo: Link to PR. Currently, we're testing these changes. We'll submit a PR to the Optimism repo after reviewing it in our own repo.

Design Doc and Specs

• SuperchainERC20: Factory Design Doc - Still in review

  All feedback has been addressed, and we've transitioned from CREATE3 to CreateX.

• Update OptimismMintableERC20Factory specs - In Progress

  Blocked by CreateX and an interface-related question.

• CreateX preinstall spec - In Progress

  We've begun working on this.

Research

• SuperchainERC20: Liquidity Migration token research - Still In Progress

  We have moved forward with simplifying the token list by adding only the historic deployment of the OptimismMintableERC20Factory and have a meeting next week to follow-up. Additionally, we will come up with solutions for tokens created outside of the factory.

Go updates

Docker-compose devnet: PR in same state, closer to unblocked,
with work on deploy and config code in OP-Stack Manager milestone 1.

Op-geth updated to 1.14.7 🎉.
Monorepo PR just got merged!

Forge-Go-script design doc was reviewed,
and we now have an initial implementation draft.
This is a path to long-term integration of deploy system and op-e2e for better testing, incl. flexible multi-L2 test setup.

Axel completed the op-supervisor executing-messages PR.

[protolambda]

Update 08/14/2024

Interop (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• Ban Deposits - Still In Progress

  Smart contracts are complete. Specs are done (with some last-minute renaming to be done). Client work continues, including tests and natspec. We plan to have a non-draft PR by the end of the week.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• OptimismSuperchainERC20 Implementation - Moved to Done

  Work completed.

• Convert Implementation - Still In Review

  Ready to be reviewed. Link to PR.

• Update OptimismMintableERC20Factory Implementation - Moved to In Review

  Ready to be reviewed. Link to PR.

• OptimismSuperchainERC20: Factory Implementation: Moved to In Progress

  We started to work on this task.

Design Doc and Specs

• SuperchainERC20 Factory Design Doc - Moved to Done.

  Merged.

• Update OptimismMintableERC20Factory specs - Moved to Done.

  Merged

• OptimismSuperchainERC20Factory specs - Moved to In Review:

  We created the PR and addressed the feedback. We also made modifications to the L2StandardBridge and OptimismMintableERC20Factory in the same predeploys.md file.

Interop Go client updates

• Axel continued work on the X-safe updating routine of the op-supervisor
  • See Interop: XSafe Head Maintainer #11458
  • At the IRL day, less available this week.
• Proto continues on forge-scripting:
  • Dependencies all sorted out: Precompile overrides, Go reflection based precompiles, and foundry artifacts FS.
  • Console precompile on the merge queue: op-chain-ops/script: ConsolePrecompile with console2 ABI #11446
  • Cleaned up the forge-scripting PR, still need to update CI to handle forge-artifacts in workspace better:
    op-chain-ops: Go forge scripts runner #11447
  • Working on the cheatcodes PR. Implemented most, still need to implement some JSON utils, although not in critical path.
• Matt Solomon is workin on OPSM 0.5, and created two drafts of the superchain deploy script:
  • original: OPSM: Deploy Superchain #11468
  • (work in progress, improvements being made based on integration discussion): OPSM: Deploy Superchain, alternate approach #11480

Once the cheatcodes PR is ready we can run through the deployment scripts of OPSM 0.5.
And then prepare the interop contracts state, with multiple L2s included,
to unblock the local-devnet PR (here)
as well as op-e2e testing of the op-supervisor.

And outside of interop we are reviewing the op-geth 1.14.8 changes, to land a snap-sync bugfix from upstream geth.

[tynes]

Kickoff 08/19/2024

Goals

• Devnet 1

Project Updates

Interop (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• Ban Deposits - !BLOCKED! Still In Progress

  Blocked due to testing; we need some guidance here.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• Convert Implementation - Still In Review

  Ready to be reviewed. Link to PR.

• Update OptimismMintableERC20Factory Implementation - Still In Review

  Ready to be reviewed. Link to PR.

• OptimismSuperchainERC20: Factory Implementation: In Progress

  The implementation has already been merged internally (Link to PR) and testing is currently under review (Link to PR). Once the review is complete, we will submit a PR to the Optimism repository.

Design Doc and Specs

• CreateX preinstall spec - In Review

  Intended to be merged simultaneously with the implementation.

• FMA - Still In Progress

  We're working on this task.

Governance (Agora) updates:

Implementation

• Advance delegation implementation

  Ready for review
  The advance delegation logic in GovernanceDelegation is ready for review. The GovernanceTokenInterop contract is being updated to reflect small changes in spec. Will also rebase PR for any changes in main.

Design Doc and Specs

• GovernanceDelegation specs update

  In progress
  Updating the GovernanceDelegation specs simplifying migration logic. Link to PR

• Governor specs

  In progress
  Resolving comments from last review. Link to PR

• Governor Interop Design Doc

  In progress

Go client update:

Supervisor Updates:
PR which add X-Safe updating is now reviwable, sans a couple auto-check issues:
#11458

This now includes test suites for new functionality

Forge script op-e2e integration

We landed all Go forge functions: #11490

The L2 genesis generation items (#11492, #11493) are being started today.
Early draft can be found in the Interop Devnet PR: #11324
We will split this into smaller PRs to land the individual genesis / setup functions.

Supervisor

Axel is continuing on the cross-safe-head maintainer functionality: #11458

Devnet

After the local devnet setup is done, and the supervisor core functions are ready,
we can run Interop op-e2e tests and local devnet.

DevX Update

[Supersim MVP]

• Nearing completion of Supersim Stage 1, Supersim that simulates interop. Focus on asset transfer and smoothing out developer experience.

• Looking to put together a small group of beta testers for Supersim as we get closer to our MVP release.

[Supersim Extensibility]

• Supersim extensibility is next focus: make it easy for 3rd parties/specialists to build on top of Supersim so that devs can test their entire app locally on Supersim. Hyperlane an early adopter here with an initial PR (Hyperlane Developer Experience Demo supersim#90) for helping devs use Supersim with Hyperlane locally!

[Reference Implementations]

• Tic Tac Toe game finishing up but due to issues with some of the UX around approving transactions multiple times it probably isn't the most compelling example of interop awesomeness.
• Need a "Hello World" that's compelling to go with launch, ideating over what that could be and how it fits into Supersim GTM.

[Interop Abstractions]

• Viem and Wagmi interop abstractions will likely be published this week or early next week, ready for use with Supersim.

[tynes]

Go client update

Devnet Genesis

branch: interopgen: based on the old deployment, but to be refactored to use the OPSM contracts.
For OPSM to work, we need to deploy the OptimismPortalInterop feature-contract.
This will exclude the Fault Proof contracts, those are blocked by further OPSM progress,
and not immediately needed for interop devnet 1.
Draft PR.

Local Devnet

branch: interop-local: depends on interopgen. In the same state, priority is on E2E.
Draft PR.

E2E tests

branch: interop-e2e: depends on interopgen.
Largely the same state as last update, with a few docs updates.
Proto/Axel to discuss how to move forward here.
Draft PR.

op-geth

We have a draft of block-building changes to utilize the op-supervisor for executing-message checks.
Blocked by op-e2e progress, to test the block-builder changes.
Draft PR.

op-node

PR ready for review: PR.
Updated op-node issue to limit devnet 1 scope more clearly: #11312
With this PR, the op-node should be ready for devnet 1 purposes.

op-supervisor

Should be feature-complete for devnet 1 purposes.
Opened an issue to track reorg handling: #11693

deposit handling

Specs landed in specs PR 258, thanks to review of @tynes.
Priority is still on E2E work, to land devnet pre-requisites.
Implementation draft is ready,
but might still need minor changes to sync with the specs PR updates.

Interop (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• Ban Deposits - Still In Progress

  The specs PR has been merged, and the testing draft PR has also been merged. Now, everything is on track to create the non-draft PR.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• OptimismSuperchainERC20: Factory Implementation - Still to Review

  In draft.

• Interop: CreateX Preinstall Implementation - Still to Review

  In draft.

• SuperchainERC20: Baseline implementation - Moved to Review

  New draft PR here.

• OptimismSuperchainERC20: Invariant Test - In Progress

  The Medusa property testing of OptimismSuperchainERC20 is close to being finished. The OptimismSuperchainERC20 formal verification is being migrated from Halmos to Kontrol. The team is working on running the tests and making optimizations as well.

Design Doc and Specs

• FMA: OptimismSuperchainERC20, Convert changes, SuperchainERC20Factory and related contracts - Still to Review

  Ready for reviews and comments.

[tynes]

Interop (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• Ban Deposits - Still In Progress

  The Final PR is under review, and we have some comments from Mark to respond to.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• Interop: CreateX Preinstall Implementation - Moved to Done

  Merged.

• OptimismSuperchainERC20: Factory Implementation - Still to Review

  We turned the draft into a PR. It has Mark's approval, but there was an issue in the CI that we are addressing. We should be ready to merge after that: PR.

• SuperchainERC20: Baseline implementation - Still to Review

  Draft PR here. We are considering making the SuperchainERC20 abstract. This should make it compatible with both non-upgradable and upgradable contracts while aligning with Solady's ERC20 design, where the ERC20 is abstract.

Design Doc and Specs

• FMA: OptimismSuperchainERC20, Convert changes, SuperchainERC20Factory and related contracts - Still to Review

  Still waiting for feedback.

Go client update

Shortest path to Devnet 1, in order:

1. Land OPSM PR
2. Land op-node PR (reviewed, needs minor updates)
3. Land OPSM-based interopgen2 PR (final steps, almost ready for review)
4. Rebase op-e2e PR onto interopgen2 (see above and below)
5. Land interop op-e2e PR (Axel is working on this)
6. Rebase and land interop-local PR for local devnet.
7. Land conditional tx PR for Transaction tx-pool invalidation marker functionality.
8. Land Interop op-e2e tests for finalization and for cross-L2 messaging.
9. Rebase op-geth interop support, use tx-pool invalidation marker
10. Merge ban deposits PR
11. Write op-e2e test for op-geth interop block-building
12. Land op-geth PR
13. Review devnet-config generation (from interop-local), to spawn long-running devnet with.
14. Cut experimental interop releases
15. Devnet time!

update:
Work focused on the E2E testing - I've made a new version of the "System" structure, and have a basic test which lets you control multiple L2s pretty cleanly with it.
Now I'm focused on adding Interop specific calls to SuperSystem (the new interface), at the moment adding Supervisor creation to the structure

Interop Governance Updates

• Interop GovToken -> Getting feedback from PR comments and waiting on decision from Interop Governor work
• Interop GovernorDelegation -> Getting feedback on PR comments and waiting on decision from Interop Governor work
• Interop Governor Work -> Working through Wonderland's comments and getting final feedback on the Governor design before moving to implementation

Sharing final PID with Kevin to align on goals of the Governance workstreams and make sure that Ben Jones and other Governance stakeholders are aligned.

DevX Update

Supersim alpha is live, you can play with interop using supersim today. Viem and wagmi interop abstractions should be published this week.

DevX team focus is on use cases, documentation, and demos as well as gathering initial feedback on the tool.

Please let me know if you try out Supersim and have thoughts/concerns! https://github.com/ethereum-optimism/supersim

[protolambda]

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• OptimismSuperchainERC20: Factory Implementation - Still to Review

  We have started addressing the CI issue internally, and it should be ready soon.

• SuperchainERC20: Baseline implementation - Still to Review

  Confirmed that we will implement the Baseline as an abstract class. We will push the changes soon as well.

Research

• ETH Withdrawals - In Progress

  We are actively considering the best approach and exploring alternative options to those already proposed. We are aware of the approaches suggested by Mark and Matt, as well as Kevin's feedback.

Go client update

Updated path to Devnet 1, in order:

1. Land OPSM PR (close to ready, @mds1 wrapping up)
2. Implement/Land OPSM Interop System Config, need help from @mds1. (update: Matt found a temporary workaround to unblock interop)
3. Land op-node PR Done!
4. Land OPSM-based interopgen2 PR: partially running, blocked by OPSM SystemConfigInterop functionality.
5. Rebase op-e2e PR onto interopgen2 (done, but breaking op-e2e draft, since OPSM is not ready yet)
6. Land interop op-e2e PR: Axel is working on this.
7. Rebase and land interop-local PR for local devnet.
8. Land conditional tx PR for Transaction tx-pool invalidation marker functionality.
   • Update: The Transaction type will hold on to the tx-pool invalidation marker bool, to de-dup with op-geth interop work.
   • Proto has reviewed most of this PR.
9. Land Interop op-e2e tests for finalization
   and for cross-L2 messaging.
   • TODO: depends on op-e2e, but that is now broken, since we rebased to interopgen2 before that was ready.
10. Land op-geth PR after rebasing
    it on top of the conditional-tx functionality, to handle tx-pool invalidation work.
11. Write op-e2e test for op-geth interop block-building (part of op-geth interop issue)
12. Land the ban deposits PR.
13. Review devnet-config generation (from interop-local), to spawn long-running devnet with.
14. Cut experimental interop releases
15. Devnet time!

Unblocked, while we are waiting for OPSM and Conditional-tx PR:

• Polish op-e2e, insofar we can, since interopgen2 base is broken.
  Might have to rebase back to interopgen with its workarounds.
• Review/land the ban-deposits op-node functionality
• Polish op-node / op-supervisor: add metrics, improve logging, etc. See UX checklist
• Supervisor improvement: Add Maintenance Trigger for Cascading Updates #11619

In parallel to interop, we also are reviewing and improving on the recent
async-gossip / conductor / sequencer start-stop issues:

• Async gossip <> sequencer continuation buffer bug
• Forkchoice update sanity checks
• Fix Stop race-condition, by mdehoog

Interop Governance Updates

• Interop GovToken -> Wrapped up reviews / comments
• Interop GovernorDelegation -> Currently blocked on reviews and feedback from Governor design document
• Interop Governor Work -> Comments addressed from the team that were left in the discord. Kent sent off the PID this past week to give the team context for a proper review. Working on the new figma file to visualize stakeholders

DevX updates: (async)

We are working on Supersim next steps and also evaluating additional tools to help devs try out interop. Focus has been on documentation and use cases for Supersim devs. We shared a first look demo for Supersim on social media: https://x.com/allam_hamdi/status/1831786304696414666

We published our viem & wagmi packages for interop abstractions:

https://www.npmjs.com/package/@eth-optimism/viem
https://www.npmjs.com/package/@eth-optimism/wagmi

The repo itself is also adding a git tag for the semvar releases of each package for example https://github.com/ethereum-optimism/ecosystem/tree/%40eth-optimism/viem%400.0.1

[tynes]

Latest Devnet 1 burndown list, in order:

1. Land OPSM PR
   Done.
2. Implement/Land OPSM Interop System Config.
   Work around successful. Interop is unblocked.
3. Land op-node PR.
   Done.
4. Land OPSM-based interopgen2 PR:
   In review.
5. Rebase op-e2e PR onto interopgen2
   Done.
6. Land interop op-e2e PR:
   Axel is working on this, near complete. Axel is OOO, but able to land this today.
7. Rebase and land interop-local PR for local devnet.
   Rebased, but needs op-e2e stability first.
8. Land conditional tx PR for Transaction tx-pool invalidation marker functionality.
   Basically ready, everyone reviewed it, few comments that should be possible to resolve? Ideally merge today.
9. Land Interop op-e2e tests for finalization
   and for cross-L2 messaging.
   TODO: depends on op-e2e work. Not started in their own capacity yet, but Axel did start on some testing already.
10. Land op-geth PR after rebasing
    it on top of the conditional-tx functionality, to handle tx-pool invalidation work.
    Proto to own this, get existing draft PR ready for review.
11. Write op-e2e test for op-geth interop block-building (part of op-geth interop issue)
    Part of the above.
12. Land the ban deposits PR.
    Done, including missing specs.
13. Review devnet-config generation (from interop-local), to spawn long-running devnet with
    Will be unblocked once the local-devnet CLI lands. Ideally we de-dup some work with op-deployer,
    but the simplified recipe, without deploy-intents, may be sufficient for dev purposes.
    TBD how we approach the final devnet deployment, maybe an early version of op-deployer,
    Matt is making great progress on the tool.
14. Cut experimental interop releases
15. Devnet time!

DevX Update

Supersim docs site: https://supersim.pages.dev/

• we'll be adding to it over the next weeks, stay tuned!

Team is focused on wrapping up some loose ends to make Supersim easier to use. Some open issues listed here: https://github.com/ethereum-optimism/supersim/issues

We are ideating on additional tools to make interop easy for devs to build on. If you have ideas or requests let me know!

Have started the next steps for viem/wagmi abstractions, which are focused on asset transfer.

DevX team has an internal hackathon scheduled for Sept. 30 to Oct. 4th, please expect delayed comms from us that week.

Interop (Wonderland) updates:

Design & Research

• Eth Withdrawals - In progress

  We have discussed all the approaches proposed and their implications internally. We all agree that the shared lockbox approach is the most logical given the current planning for interop. We will proceed by drafting a design doc and then schedule a design review meeting before moving on to the spec. Also we will respond to the issue and continue the discussion on Discord.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• OptimismSuperchainERC20: Factory Implementation - Still to Review

  It should be ready for review again. We encountered two conflicts at different times, so we had to rebase twice in case you want to check the history.

• SuperchainERC20: Baseline implementation - Still to Review

  There are a few small conflicts to fix, and then we’ll be ready to have it reviewed again with the abstract implementation. It should be ready later today or tomorrow.

Design & Research

• Custom Implementation Factory - Moved to In Progress

  In the design phase, and the design doc will be ready for early discussion soon.

[protolambda]

13 Sept

Interop (Wonderland) updates:

Design & Research

• Eth Withdrawals - In progress

  We have shared an internal document explaining different solutions and the most preferred one. New flows required and edge cases found were covered for discussion.

Superc20 (Wonderland) updates:

Implementation

• OptimismSuperchainERC20: Factory Implementation - Moved to Done

  Merged!

• SuperchainERC20: Baseline implementation - Still to Review

  Addressing Mark's latest comments and fixing interfaces to comply with the CI.

Design & Research

• Custom Implementation Factory - Still In Progress

  The design doc is almost ready. We will create the PR today or on Monday.

Go update

Updated devnet 1 burndown list:

1. Land OPSM PR
   Done.
2. Implement/Land OPSM Interop System Config.
   Work around successful. Interop is unblocked.
3. Land op-node PR.
   Done.
4. Land OPSM-based interopgen2 PR:
   In active review.
5. Rebase op-e2e PR onto interopgen2
   Done.
6. Land interop op-e2e PR:
   Reviewed, one minor issue left, ready to merge as soon as interopgen2 lands.
7. Rebase and land interop-local PR for local devnet.
   Rebased, but needs op-e2e stability first, before review/merge.
8. Land conditional tx PR for Transaction tx-pool invalidation marker functionality.
   Done.
9. Land Interop op-e2e tests for finalization
   and for cross-L2 messaging.
   Priority today, besides landing the in-review things. Split between Proto / Axel. Coordinate in interop-client channel.
10. Land op-geth PR after rebasing.
    Ready for review, but blocked by below testing item.
11. Write op-e2e test for op-geth interop block-building (part of op-geth interop issue)
    Todo today/tomorrow, Proto to own.
12. Land the ban deposits PR.
    Done.
13. interop-local / interopgen2 / op-deployer:
    deployment of devnet needs more coordination, Matt/Proto to work on this together.
14. Cut experimental interop releases
15. Devnet time!