-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 12.8k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
add some comments and some cleanup around Miri intptrcast #116650
Conversation
r? @b-naber (rustbot has picked a reviewer for you, use r? to override) |
The Miri subtree was changed cc @rust-lang/miri Some changes occurred to the CTFE / Miri engine cc @rust-lang/miri |
src/tools/miri/src/intptrcast.rs
Outdated
// We do *not* look up the `AllocId` here! This is a `ptr as usize` cast, and it is | ||
// completely legal to do a cast and then `wrapping_offset` to another allocation and only | ||
// *then* do a memory access. So the allocation that the pointer happens to point to on a | ||
// cast is fairly irrelevant. Instead we generate this as a "wildcard" point, such that | ||
// *every time the pointer is used*, we do an `AllocId` lookup to find the (exposed) | ||
// allocation it might be referencing. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
I do not have any objection to the rest of this PR, but this is by far the most helpful change. I'm not sure we really explain that this is how wildcard pointers behave anywhere else.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Ah, good point! Yes indeed we entirely forgot about that.
I added a doc comment to Pointer::Wildcard
that explains the general principle even more.
The Miri subtree was changed cc @rust-lang/miri Some changes occurred to the CTFE / Miri engine cc @rust-lang/miri |
fcb6b42
to
e92c934
Compare
r? @oli-obk |
@bors r+ rollup |
…iaskrgr Rollup of 4 pull requests Successful merges: - rust-lang#116650 (add some comments and some cleanup around Miri intptrcast) - rust-lang#116896 (Only check in a single place if a pass is enabled.) - rust-lang#116906 (Use v0.0.0 in compiler crates) - rust-lang#116921 (fix(bootstrap) info message show correct path now) r? `@ghost` `@rustbot` modify labels: rollup
Rollup merge of rust-lang#116650 - RalfJung:miri-intptrcast, r=oli-obk add some comments and some cleanup around Miri intptrcast `@saethlin` maybe this helps a bit?
74: Automated pull from upstream `master` r=tshepang a=github-actions[bot] This PR pulls the following changes from the upstream repository: * rust-lang/rust#117363 * rust-lang/rust#116405 * rust-lang/rust#117415 * rust-lang/rust#117414 * rust-lang/rust#117411 * rust-lang/rust#117403 * rust-lang/rust#117398 * rust-lang/rust#117396 * rust-lang/rust#117389 * rust-lang/rust#116862 * rust-lang/rust#117405 * rust-lang/rust#117395 * rust-lang/rust#117390 * rust-lang/rust#117383 * rust-lang/rust#117376 * rust-lang/rust#117370 * rust-lang/rust#117357 * rust-lang/rust#117356 * rust-lang/rust#117317 * rust-lang/rust#117132 * rust-lang/rust#117068 * rust-lang/rust#112463 * rust-lang/rust#117267 * rust-lang/rust#116939 * rust-lang/rust#117387 * rust-lang/rust#117385 * rust-lang/rust#117382 * rust-lang/rust#117371 * rust-lang/rust#117365 * rust-lang/rust#117350 * rust-lang/rust#117205 * rust-lang/rust#117177 * rust-lang/rust#117147 * rust-lang/rust#116485 * rust-lang/rust#117328 * rust-lang/rust#117332 * rust-lang/rust#117089 * rust-lang/rust#116733 * rust-lang/rust#116889 * rust-lang/rust#116270 * rust-lang/rust#117354 * rust-lang/rust#117337 * rust-lang/rust#117312 * rust-lang/rust#117082 * rust-lang/rust#117043 * rust-lang/rust#115968 * rust-lang/rust#117336 * rust-lang/rust#117325 * rust-lang/rust#117322 * rust-lang/rust#117259 * rust-lang/rust#117170 * rust-lang/rust#117335 * rust-lang/rust#117319 * rust-lang/rust#117316 * rust-lang/rust#117311 * rust-lang/rust#117162 * rust-lang/rust#115773 * rust-lang/rust#116447 * rust-lang/rust#117149 * rust-lang/rust#116240 * rust-lang/rust#117123 * rust-lang/rust#81746 * rust-lang/rust#117038 * rust-lang/rust#116609 * rust-lang/rust#117309 * rust-lang/rust#117277 * rust-lang/rust#117268 * rust-lang/rust#117256 * rust-lang/rust#117025 * rust-lang/rust#116945 * rust-lang/rust#116816 * rust-lang/rust#116739 * rust-lang/rust#116534 * rust-lang/rust#117253 * rust-lang/rust#117302 * rust-lang/rust#117197 * rust-lang/rust#116471 * rust-lang/rust#117294 * rust-lang/rust#117287 * rust-lang/rust#117281 * rust-lang/rust#117270 * rust-lang/rust#117247 * rust-lang/rust#117246 * rust-lang/rust#117212 * rust-lang/rust#116834 * rust-lang/rust#103208 * rust-lang/rust#117166 * rust-lang/rust#116751 * rust-lang/rust#116858 * rust-lang/rust#117272 * rust-lang/rust#117266 * rust-lang/rust#117262 * rust-lang/rust#117241 * rust-lang/rust#117240 * rust-lang/rust#116868 * rust-lang/rust#114998 * rust-lang/rust#116205 * rust-lang/rust#117260 * rust-lang/rust#116035 * rust-lang/rust#113183 * rust-lang/rust#117249 * rust-lang/rust#117243 * rust-lang/rust#117188 * rust-lang/rust#117114 * rust-lang/rust#117106 * rust-lang/rust#117032 * rust-lang/rust#116968 * rust-lang/rust#116581 * rust-lang/rust#117228 * rust-lang/rust#117221 * rust-lang/rust#117214 * rust-lang/rust#117207 * rust-lang/rust#117202 * rust-lang/rust#117194 * rust-lang/rust#117143 * rust-lang/rust#117095 * rust-lang/rust#116905 * rust-lang/rust#117171 * rust-lang/rust#113262 * rust-lang/rust#112875 * rust-lang/rust#116983 * rust-lang/rust#117148 * rust-lang/rust#117115 * rust-lang/rust#116818 * rust-lang/rust#115872 * rust-lang/rust#117193 * rust-lang/rust#117175 * rust-lang/rust#117009 * rust-lang/rust#117008 * rust-lang/rust#116931 * rust-lang/rust#116553 * rust-lang/rust#116401 * rust-lang/rust#117180 * rust-lang/rust#117173 * rust-lang/rust#117163 * rust-lang/rust#117159 * rust-lang/rust#117154 * rust-lang/rust#117152 * rust-lang/rust#117141 * rust-lang/rust#117111 * rust-lang/rust#117172 * rust-lang/rust#117168 * rust-lang/rust#117160 * rust-lang/rust#117158 * rust-lang/rust#117150 * rust-lang/rust#117136 * rust-lang/rust#117133 * rust-lang/rust#116801 * rust-lang/rust#117165 * rust-lang/rust#117113 * rust-lang/rust#117102 * rust-lang/rust#117076 * rust-lang/rust#116236 * rust-lang/rust#116993 * rust-lang/rust#117139 * rust-lang/rust#116482 * rust-lang/rust#115796 * rust-lang/rust#117135 * rust-lang/rust#117127 * rust-lang/rust#117010 * rust-lang/rust#116943 * rust-lang/rust#116841 * rust-lang/rust#116792 * rust-lang/rust#116714 * rust-lang/rust#116396 * rust-lang/rust#116094 * rust-lang/rust#117126 * rust-lang/rust#117105 * rust-lang/rust#117093 * rust-lang/rust#117092 * rust-lang/rust#117091 * rust-lang/rust#117081 * rust-lang/rust#116773 * rust-lang/rust#117124 * rust-lang/rust#116461 * rust-lang/rust#116435 * rust-lang/rust#116319 * rust-lang/rust#116238 * rust-lang/rust#116998 * rust-lang/rust#116300 * rust-lang/rust#117103 * rust-lang/rust#117086 * rust-lang/rust#117074 * rust-lang/rust#117070 * rust-lang/rust#117046 * rust-lang/rust#116859 * rust-lang/rust#107159 * rust-lang/rust#116033 * rust-lang/rust#107009 * rust-lang/rust#117087 * rust-lang/rust#117073 * rust-lang/rust#117064 * rust-lang/rust#117040 * rust-lang/rust#116978 * rust-lang/rust#116960 * rust-lang/rust#116837 * rust-lang/rust#116835 * rust-lang/rust#116849 * rust-lang/rust#117071 * rust-lang/rust#117069 * rust-lang/rust#117051 * rust-lang/rust#117049 * rust-lang/rust#117044 * rust-lang/rust#117042 * rust-lang/rust#105666 * rust-lang/rust#116606 * rust-lang/rust#117066 * rust-lang/rust#115324 * rust-lang/rust#117062 * rust-lang/rust#117000 * rust-lang/rust#117007 * rust-lang/rust#117018 * rust-lang/rust#116256 * rust-lang/rust#117041 * rust-lang/rust#117037 * rust-lang/rust#117034 * rust-lang/rust#116989 * rust-lang/rust#116985 * rust-lang/rust#116950 * rust-lang/rust#116956 * rust-lang/rust#116932 * rust-lang/rust#117031 * rust-lang/rust#117030 * rust-lang/rust#117028 * rust-lang/rust#117026 * rust-lang/rust#116992 * rust-lang/rust#116981 * rust-lang/rust#116955 * rust-lang/rust#116928 * rust-lang/rust#116312 * rust-lang/rust#116368 * rust-lang/rust#116922 * rust-lang/rust#117021 * rust-lang/rust#117020 * rust-lang/rust#117019 * rust-lang/rust#116975 * rust-lang/rust#106601 * rust-lang/rust#116734 * rust-lang/rust#117013 * rust-lang/rust#116995 * rust-lang/rust#116990 * rust-lang/rust#116974 * rust-lang/rust#116964 * rust-lang/rust#116961 * rust-lang/rust#116917 * rust-lang/rust#116911 * rust-lang/rust#114521 * rust-lang/rust#117011 * rust-lang/rust#116958 * rust-lang/rust#116951 * rust-lang/rust#116966 * rust-lang/rust#116965 * rust-lang/rust#116962 * rust-lang/rust#116946 * rust-lang/rust#116899 * rust-lang/rust#116785 * rust-lang/rust#116838 * rust-lang/rust#116875 * rust-lang/rust#116874 * rust-lang/rust#115214 * rust-lang/rust#116810 * rust-lang/rust#116940 * rust-lang/rust#116921 * rust-lang/rust#116906 * rust-lang/rust#116896 * rust-lang/rust#116650 * rust-lang/rust#116132 * rust-lang/rust#116037 * rust-lang/rust#116923 * rust-lang/rust#116912 * rust-lang/rust#116908 * rust-lang/rust#116883 * rust-lang/rust#116829 * rust-lang/rust#116795 * rust-lang/rust#116761 * rust-lang/rust#116663 * rust-lang/rust#114534 * rust-lang/rust#116402 * rust-lang/rust#116493 * rust-lang/rust#116046 * rust-lang/rust#116887 * rust-lang/rust#116885 * rust-lang/rust#116879 * rust-lang/rust#116870 * rust-lang/rust#116865 * rust-lang/rust#116856 * rust-lang/rust#116812 * rust-lang/rust#116815 * rust-lang/rust#116814 * rust-lang/rust#116713 * rust-lang/rust#116830 Co-authored-by: Matthias Krüger <matthias.krueger@famsik.de> Co-authored-by: antoyo <antoyo@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Antoni Boucher <bouanto@zoho.com> Co-authored-by: bors <bors@rust-lang.org> Co-authored-by: Esteban Küber <esteban@kuber.com.ar> Co-authored-by: Kjetil Kjeka <kjetilkjeka@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: clubby789 <jamie@hill-daniel.co.uk> Co-authored-by: okaneco <47607823+okaneco@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: David Tolnay <dtolnay@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Nadrieril <nadrieril+git@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Celina G. Val <celinval@amazon.com> Co-authored-by: Ralf Jung <post@ralfj.de> Co-authored-by: Zalathar <Zalathar@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Havard Eidnes <he@NetBSD.org> Co-authored-by: Jacob Pratt <jacob@jhpratt.dev> Co-authored-by: Kjetil Kjeka <kjetil@muybridge.com>
74: Automated pull from upstream `master` r=tshepang a=github-actions[bot] This PR pulls the following changes from the upstream repository: * rust-lang/rust#117363 * rust-lang/rust#116405 * rust-lang/rust#117415 * rust-lang/rust#117414 * rust-lang/rust#117411 * rust-lang/rust#117403 * rust-lang/rust#117398 * rust-lang/rust#117396 * rust-lang/rust#117389 * rust-lang/rust#116862 * rust-lang/rust#117405 * rust-lang/rust#117395 * rust-lang/rust#117390 * rust-lang/rust#117383 * rust-lang/rust#117376 * rust-lang/rust#117370 * rust-lang/rust#117357 * rust-lang/rust#117356 * rust-lang/rust#117317 * rust-lang/rust#117132 * rust-lang/rust#117068 * rust-lang/rust#112463 * rust-lang/rust#117267 * rust-lang/rust#116939 * rust-lang/rust#117387 * rust-lang/rust#117385 * rust-lang/rust#117382 * rust-lang/rust#117371 * rust-lang/rust#117365 * rust-lang/rust#117350 * rust-lang/rust#117205 * rust-lang/rust#117177 * rust-lang/rust#117147 * rust-lang/rust#116485 * rust-lang/rust#117328 * rust-lang/rust#117332 * rust-lang/rust#117089 * rust-lang/rust#116733 * rust-lang/rust#116889 * rust-lang/rust#116270 * rust-lang/rust#117354 * rust-lang/rust#117337 * rust-lang/rust#117312 * rust-lang/rust#117082 * rust-lang/rust#117043 * rust-lang/rust#115968 * rust-lang/rust#117336 * rust-lang/rust#117325 * rust-lang/rust#117322 * rust-lang/rust#117259 * rust-lang/rust#117170 * rust-lang/rust#117335 * rust-lang/rust#117319 * rust-lang/rust#117316 * rust-lang/rust#117311 * rust-lang/rust#117162 * rust-lang/rust#115773 * rust-lang/rust#116447 * rust-lang/rust#117149 * rust-lang/rust#116240 * rust-lang/rust#117123 * rust-lang/rust#81746 * rust-lang/rust#117038 * rust-lang/rust#116609 * rust-lang/rust#117309 * rust-lang/rust#117277 * rust-lang/rust#117268 * rust-lang/rust#117256 * rust-lang/rust#117025 * rust-lang/rust#116945 * rust-lang/rust#116816 * rust-lang/rust#116739 * rust-lang/rust#116534 * rust-lang/rust#117253 * rust-lang/rust#117302 * rust-lang/rust#117197 * rust-lang/rust#116471 * rust-lang/rust#117294 * rust-lang/rust#117287 * rust-lang/rust#117281 * rust-lang/rust#117270 * rust-lang/rust#117247 * rust-lang/rust#117246 * rust-lang/rust#117212 * rust-lang/rust#116834 * rust-lang/rust#103208 * rust-lang/rust#117166 * rust-lang/rust#116751 * rust-lang/rust#116858 * rust-lang/rust#117272 * rust-lang/rust#117266 * rust-lang/rust#117262 * rust-lang/rust#117241 * rust-lang/rust#117240 * rust-lang/rust#116868 * rust-lang/rust#114998 * rust-lang/rust#116205 * rust-lang/rust#117260 * rust-lang/rust#116035 * rust-lang/rust#113183 * rust-lang/rust#117249 * rust-lang/rust#117243 * rust-lang/rust#117188 * rust-lang/rust#117114 * rust-lang/rust#117106 * rust-lang/rust#117032 * rust-lang/rust#116968 * rust-lang/rust#116581 * rust-lang/rust#117228 * rust-lang/rust#117221 * rust-lang/rust#117214 * rust-lang/rust#117207 * rust-lang/rust#117202 * rust-lang/rust#117194 * rust-lang/rust#117143 * rust-lang/rust#117095 * rust-lang/rust#116905 * rust-lang/rust#117171 * rust-lang/rust#113262 * rust-lang/rust#112875 * rust-lang/rust#116983 * rust-lang/rust#117148 * rust-lang/rust#117115 * rust-lang/rust#116818 * rust-lang/rust#115872 * rust-lang/rust#117193 * rust-lang/rust#117175 * rust-lang/rust#117009 * rust-lang/rust#117008 * rust-lang/rust#116931 * rust-lang/rust#116553 * rust-lang/rust#116401 * rust-lang/rust#117180 * rust-lang/rust#117173 * rust-lang/rust#117163 * rust-lang/rust#117159 * rust-lang/rust#117154 * rust-lang/rust#117152 * rust-lang/rust#117141 * rust-lang/rust#117111 * rust-lang/rust#117172 * rust-lang/rust#117168 * rust-lang/rust#117160 * rust-lang/rust#117158 * rust-lang/rust#117150 * rust-lang/rust#117136 * rust-lang/rust#117133 * rust-lang/rust#116801 * rust-lang/rust#117165 * rust-lang/rust#117113 * rust-lang/rust#117102 * rust-lang/rust#117076 * rust-lang/rust#116236 * rust-lang/rust#116993 * rust-lang/rust#117139 * rust-lang/rust#116482 * rust-lang/rust#115796 * rust-lang/rust#117135 * rust-lang/rust#117127 * rust-lang/rust#117010 * rust-lang/rust#116943 * rust-lang/rust#116841 * rust-lang/rust#116792 * rust-lang/rust#116714 * rust-lang/rust#116396 * rust-lang/rust#116094 * rust-lang/rust#117126 * rust-lang/rust#117105 * rust-lang/rust#117093 * rust-lang/rust#117092 * rust-lang/rust#117091 * rust-lang/rust#117081 * rust-lang/rust#116773 * rust-lang/rust#117124 * rust-lang/rust#116461 * rust-lang/rust#116435 * rust-lang/rust#116319 * rust-lang/rust#116238 * rust-lang/rust#116998 * rust-lang/rust#116300 * rust-lang/rust#117103 * rust-lang/rust#117086 * rust-lang/rust#117074 * rust-lang/rust#117070 * rust-lang/rust#117046 * rust-lang/rust#116859 * rust-lang/rust#107159 * rust-lang/rust#116033 * rust-lang/rust#107009 * rust-lang/rust#117087 * rust-lang/rust#117073 * rust-lang/rust#117064 * rust-lang/rust#117040 * rust-lang/rust#116978 * rust-lang/rust#116960 * rust-lang/rust#116837 * rust-lang/rust#116835 * rust-lang/rust#116849 * rust-lang/rust#117071 * rust-lang/rust#117069 * rust-lang/rust#117051 * rust-lang/rust#117049 * rust-lang/rust#117044 * rust-lang/rust#117042 * rust-lang/rust#105666 * rust-lang/rust#116606 * rust-lang/rust#117066 * rust-lang/rust#115324 * rust-lang/rust#117062 * rust-lang/rust#117000 * rust-lang/rust#117007 * rust-lang/rust#117018 * rust-lang/rust#116256 * rust-lang/rust#117041 * rust-lang/rust#117037 * rust-lang/rust#117034 * rust-lang/rust#116989 * rust-lang/rust#116985 * rust-lang/rust#116950 * rust-lang/rust#116956 * rust-lang/rust#116932 * rust-lang/rust#117031 * rust-lang/rust#117030 * rust-lang/rust#117028 * rust-lang/rust#117026 * rust-lang/rust#116992 * rust-lang/rust#116981 * rust-lang/rust#116955 * rust-lang/rust#116928 * rust-lang/rust#116312 * rust-lang/rust#116368 * rust-lang/rust#116922 * rust-lang/rust#117021 * rust-lang/rust#117020 * rust-lang/rust#117019 * rust-lang/rust#116975 * rust-lang/rust#106601 * rust-lang/rust#116734 * rust-lang/rust#117013 * rust-lang/rust#116995 * rust-lang/rust#116990 * rust-lang/rust#116974 * rust-lang/rust#116964 * rust-lang/rust#116961 * rust-lang/rust#116917 * rust-lang/rust#116911 * rust-lang/rust#114521 * rust-lang/rust#117011 * rust-lang/rust#116958 * rust-lang/rust#116951 * rust-lang/rust#116966 * rust-lang/rust#116965 * rust-lang/rust#116962 * rust-lang/rust#116946 * rust-lang/rust#116899 * rust-lang/rust#116785 * rust-lang/rust#116838 * rust-lang/rust#116875 * rust-lang/rust#116874 * rust-lang/rust#115214 * rust-lang/rust#116810 * rust-lang/rust#116940 * rust-lang/rust#116921 * rust-lang/rust#116906 * rust-lang/rust#116896 * rust-lang/rust#116650 * rust-lang/rust#116132 * rust-lang/rust#116037 * rust-lang/rust#116923 * rust-lang/rust#116912 * rust-lang/rust#116908 * rust-lang/rust#116883 * rust-lang/rust#116829 * rust-lang/rust#116795 * rust-lang/rust#116761 * rust-lang/rust#116663 * rust-lang/rust#114534 * rust-lang/rust#116402 * rust-lang/rust#116493 * rust-lang/rust#116046 * rust-lang/rust#116887 * rust-lang/rust#116885 * rust-lang/rust#116879 * rust-lang/rust#116870 * rust-lang/rust#116865 * rust-lang/rust#116856 * rust-lang/rust#116812 * rust-lang/rust#116815 * rust-lang/rust#116814 * rust-lang/rust#116713 * rust-lang/rust#116830 Co-authored-by: antoyo <antoyo@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Antoni Boucher <bouanto@zoho.com> Co-authored-by: bors <bors@rust-lang.org> Co-authored-by: Esteban Küber <esteban@kuber.com.ar> Co-authored-by: Kjetil Kjeka <kjetilkjeka@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: clubby789 <jamie@hill-daniel.co.uk> Co-authored-by: okaneco <47607823+okaneco@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: David Tolnay <dtolnay@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Nadrieril <nadrieril+git@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Celina G. Val <celinval@amazon.com> Co-authored-by: Ralf Jung <post@ralfj.de> Co-authored-by: Zalathar <Zalathar@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Havard Eidnes <he@NetBSD.org> Co-authored-by: Jacob Pratt <jacob@jhpratt.dev> Co-authored-by: Kjetil Kjeka <kjetil@muybridge.com> Co-authored-by: Matthias Krüger <matthias.krueger@famsik.de>
@saethlin maybe this helps a bit?