[TRACKER] DisplayServer, Window & UI issues

[mhilbrunner]

Tracker for DisplayServer/Window bugs in 4.0. Feel free to edit.

DisplayServer PR: #37317

Multi-window proposal: godotengine/godot-proposals#28

Bugs

• All popups close when the main window is hidden, minimized, moved or resized #37732
• Creating or choosing a folder when creating a project closes all popups and doesn't create the project #37731
• Error each Godot start at DisplayServerWindows::cursor_set_shape()/VulkanContext::window_resize() #37730
• Help window closes when filter is selected #37710
• Editor crash on exit due to not unregistered callbacks #37548
• Focus problems with popup menus #37531
• File explorer Window is wrapped when clicking Browse in import dailog, missing icons and unable to import projects. #37401
• DisplayServerWindows handles event multiple times #37425
• dialog window title bar are visible in Windows(os) #37377
• Editor crash when minimizing on Windows (crash in VulkanContext::prepare_buffers) #37327
• Profiler frame number stops updating when game window is minimized #37341
• SceneTreeDock loses focus when changing Node's name & db-click not working #37335
• Godot opens popup like AcceptDialog even if project is not running #37334
• Creating a node by double-click will create two copies #37331
• Window has empty limits section in the inspector #37330
• Editor crash when creating Window node #37329
• Restoring minimized Project Manager makes it bigger #37328
• Sub-windows don't move smoothly #37325
• Project Manager appears in the corner of the screen #37323
• Permanent black rectangle #37322
• Windows always appear on first screen #37320
• Single-mode windows are not clipped to top-left coords when dragged #37792
• Increasing editor window size shows incorrect graphics #38311
• Rightclick context menu generation uses screen offset instead of window offset. #38591
• Some dialogue window open too small #38726
• Multiple editor theme propagation errors. #39235
• Menu's become new windows and other windows exit as soon as mouse leaves #39596
• OptionButton item cannot be selected due to immediate closing after mouse released #40227
• Scene Node drag & drop glitchy #39087
• Godot 4.0.dev editor behaves weird while using i3wm (and maybe other tilling wm's) #37930
• Popups don't fit into screen #45199
• Popups may appear with huge offset when right-clicking unfocused editor #45200
• Unintended window size changes (DisplayServer regression) #58032
• Enabling fullscreen via code shows window border at screen edges (DisplayServer regression) #63500

May be relevant

• The cursor remains a "text cursor" when a text input control is selected in the inspector #37724
• Stretch Shrink project setting does not work #37941
• Can't select rows in editor help, because dragging mouse scrolls (ScrollContainer touch input emulation bug) #38665
• Fullscreen setting is broken #37588
• Editor crash when opening and closing immediately project #37665
• Godot crash when clicking at color picker #37520
• LineEdit caret sometimes invisible in sub-window #37748
• Most drag and drop functionality does not work #38312
• [4.0] Camera2D's preview box uses editor viewport size instead of project settings size #38316
• Increasing editor window size shows incorrect graphics #38311
• Node renaming in tree no longer occurs on double click, and visual of renaming node is not as clean #38817
• 2D stretch mode doesn't scale properly #39892

Pull requests

• Project manager window position bug fix: #37323 #37366
  • Superseded by display server window position bug fix #37802
• Window minimize crash fix: #37327 #37382
  • Superseded by Editor crash when minimizing on Windows (crash in VulkanContext::prepare_buffers) #37327
• Fix: creating Node by double-click creates two copies #37389
• [macOS] Fix popup positions on multiple screens. #37430
• Improve editor popups with multiple screens #37506
• Fix input event being dispatched multiple times on Windows #37519
• Fix popup positioning with multiple monitors #37528
• Windows: Fix crash on application exit due to not unregistered callbacks #37549
• Added missing modal_closed signal #37557
• popup window position adjustment bug fix #37559
• Reimplement MenuButton::switch_on_hover #37771
• Fix popup closing when parent window is focused related issues. #39145
• Fix window size change when restoring from minimized state #39640
• Fixes for windows in X11 tiling WMs #38727

[YuriSizov]

Most of this tracker is now fixed, and the remaining couple of issues are out of scope for 4.0 at this point. I'm going to close this issue. Feel free to report new problems if you run into them.